Originally Posted by
the Wasp
gee, if an APC 18x8 unload's and over revs in the air by 1000 RPM, and Saito recommends a prop as small as a 15x8, I have to wonder how much a 15x8 would over rev in the air
Jim
Have you actually used the calculator linked previously to plug in a 15 x 8 at 9300 RPM?
15 x 8 @ 9300 RPM 68*F generates 11.94# of static thrust and absorbs 2.213 HP
You think that might be a typo on Horizon Hobby's site?
So maybe they meant 16 x 8.
16 x 8 @ 9300 RPM 68*F generates 15.54# of static thrust and absorbs 2.865 HP
Sound more reasonable?
Lets plug in an 18 x 8 @ 7900 RPM as I have observed with my FA-180 with glow ignition.
18 X 8 @ 7900 RPM generates 17.86# of static thrust and absorbs 2.813 HP
Hmmm, 15% more static thrust and more RPM in reserve for higher air speed. Seems the 18 x 8 is more efficient.
So now lets plug in the RPM numbers observed for my CDI stock FA-180 and the various high compression versions with CDI.
Otherwise stock FA-180 with CDI
18 x 8 @ 8000 RPM generates 18.32# of static thrust and absorbs 2.921 HP
FA-180/FG-57 piston 11:1 CR with CDI;
18 x 8 @ 8150 RPM generates 19.01# of static thrust and absorbs 3.088HP
FA-180 .032" deck reduction 12.8:1 CR CDI;
18 x 8 @ 8300 RPM generates 19.72# of static thrust and absorbs 3.262 HP
Same engine with 12mm FA-220 big bore carburetor and ported intake manifold with CDI;
18 x 8 @ 8450 RPM generates 20.44# of static thrust and absorbs 3.442 HP
If I up the nitro from 15% to 30% and reduce the lube content to 8% the same engine will turn the 18 X 8 @ 8850 RPM
18 x 8 @ 8850 RPM generates 22.452# of static thrust and absorbs 3.954 HP