RCU Forums - View Single Post - dihedral wing vs 4 ch
View Single Post
Old 05-15-2019 | 11:40 AM
  #11  
Hydro Junkie's Avatar
Hydro Junkie
 
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 10,629
Received 139 Likes on 132 Posts
From: Marysville, WA
Default

Originally Posted by speedracerntrixie
I think there is going to be different opinions on this subject simply because we have differnt views on what performance and stability mean. There really is nothing saying that additional dihedral will reduce aileron authority. It will however create a control cross couple. Many of us long time R/C pilots with little to no full scale experience tend to View stability as the airplanes capability to go where pointed and stay on that line. Full scale guys think as stability in term of the airplane being able to somewhat right itself.

And I tend to agree with much of this due to the fact that, when comparing an R/C to a full sized plane, the weight of the full sized plane is generally going to give it less stability(especially with a low wing design) than an RC due to the higher wing loading and the shifting weight of the occupants and load, including fuel. A full sized plane is also affected by winds more than an R/C due to the larger side area. If you watch a plane flying toward or away from you closely, it won't be pointing the direction it's flying but, rather, it will be crabbing into the wind. This is something an R/C never has to contend with, other than during the final approach to the landing area.
Originally Posted by speedracerntrixie
One trend I see which full scale guys is the misconception that aerobatic airplanes must be less stable, more difficult to fly and are snap/stall happy.
That is not a misconception, other than the being difficult to fly. If you look at the control systems in any of the front line fighter planes used by the US military, you will find they are all routed through a flight control computer due the the aircraft being so unstable that they are almost impossible to fly without said computer. The Extras, Edges, Eagles, etc, that are commonly seen on the show circuit are all also built to be unstable so the planes can do all the stunts that "WOW" the crowds. No one wants to see a plane slow roll when they expect to see a snap roll. A more stable aircraft may perform a roll but the rolls won't be sharp or crisp due to inertia and weight.