RCU Forums - View Single Post - The truth about servos
View Single Post
Old 12-24-2020, 01:08 PM
  #21  
jvaliensi
My Feedback: (1)
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: northridge, CA
Posts: 761
Received 111 Likes on 89 Posts
Default

I did a little testing using my ToolKitRC servo tester. It reads out the current the servo is using in real time.
I clamped the servo to my bench and suspended 675g from a 20mm servo arm. I recorded the idle amps with no load, the amps to lift the weight and the idle current with the weight attached.

MKS 747: idle 28mA, idle w/ load 200mA, moving 675mA

Futaba BLS173SV: idle 26mA, idle w/ load 26mA or 300mA*, moving 960mA

Savox SV1261MG: idle 10mA, idle w/ load 310mA or 10mA*, moving 1,700mA

Promodler DS100DV; Idle 10mA, idle w/ load 531mA or 10mA*, moving 950mA

The Futaba would go to idle current with the load attached. The Savox and Promodler will too, but I had to play with the output signal. The MKS would not go to idle current with a load. This may be due to how the control algorithm is written between different brands.
It leads me to think the MKS will use more energy over time.

The Savox & MKS are rated at the same torque, but the Savox drew more current to move the same load.

I like the way the Futaba went to idle amps and quit buzzing with the load attached. I'm not sure they are strong enough for flaps on a 14lbs jet.