If it is something he is interested in and will stick with, go with one of the first two. If it is something he is going to be interested in for the 10 or 15 minutes till he crashes it, go with one of the second.

As stated, they are really not the same. The first two are re-usable RC planes that he can learn on and move on and use the engine and radio again on other planes. The other two are more less disposable planes that he may have fun with for a short time, but won't stick with the hobby long flying them.

Just my observations from watching people fly both.