ORIGINAL: Ross Kean
I think the most important part of the question is not kit, ARF or RTF. The greatest change for the mainstream in this hobby is going to be mode of propulsion!
Electric power, in my opinion, will overtake glow in the next five years. If the advances in battery technology and motors we have seen in the past couple of years continue and prices continue to drop there will be little reason to consider glow power for anything other than special applications. In five to ten years your sport 46 glow engine may be a dinosaur.
Having said this, I am just starting with medium power electrics and am dealing with battery weight (NiMH rather than LiPo), charging considerations and a relatively high initial cost. Performance costs money and I am probably going to have to settle for less than ideal power at this stage. The battery cost is probably similar to the cost of the fuel it replaces but there is significant up-front investment. I am looking forward to MUCH less noise and not having to clean the slime from my airplane at the end of the day. Also just starting the learning process and will, no doubt, continue to fly glow for some time to come.
No matter if you build (kit), assemble (ARF), or fly out of the box (RTF) this is a great hobby with more than enough variety to keep anyone interested for a long time.
Ross
Ross is right. I'm pretty new to this sport, and I can see that electric will eventually be the way to go for everything, as will ARF and RTF planes. That said, the glow planes and kits/scratchbuilds won't disappear. I ride a motorcycle, but I can ride a horse, too. The true craftsmanship involved in a kit plane appeals to a lot of people, and it is something I intend to tackle myself one day. But, for now, ARF and RTF planes are the way to go, especially for beginner/intermediate flyers.
Just my 2 cents.
Ray out