An even better choice is neither . Instead, look at the Venture 60 by Bruce Tharpe Engineering. Bruce is the original designer of the Four Star (when he worked for SIG). But he now has his own company, the flagship of which is the Venture 60.

The Venture 60 is the 'next generation' of the Four Star. While the two are quite similar, the V60 is clearly an updated design.

Check out the Venture60 web site.