If a person buys a HL tank and it works well, then that is all that is important. [sm=thumbup.gif] I enjoyed detailing and playing with my HL Tiger 1 (when it worked) just as much as as I do the Tamiyas. After all, they are able to handle the same terraine and the details are really good on both brands, so I agree that HL tanks are definitely a great alternative to the high dollar Tamiya tanks.
With the variety and quality of upgrades that are becoming available for the HL tanks, they can be made better and better, so I would not put them down for their price tag. I just happen to have had a bad experience with the two that I have had, so I do not recommend them in the event that they turn out to be a bad investment for a first-timer.
You're right, it is nice to have a tank that shoots.

The main thing is that we all have something to customize and enjoy, no matter what the price range.
Good luck with your tank! [sm=thumbup.gif]
Jason