ORIGINAL: chris77
My point is you learned when sim's were not around, and now sim's are around and your giving advice that's not current to what is avalable, you discount first hand knowledge and blow out of purportion the numbers of failures. Both ways are good and both ways have failures.
Sure, that's it, we've been doing this too long.

A very small minority manages to learn to fly on their own with a sim and suddenly anyone who suggests that method is less than ideal is giving outdated information. As I've said, there's much more to flying than one can get with as sim. While some can learn this way, it's less than ideal, and way more fail tham succeed. Most people understand the value of learning from experience. Others feel they need to rediscover things on their own. Oh well, to each his own.