ORIGINAL: XJet
I used to run BelRay back in the 1970s when I rode motorcross and could not believe that it provided as much protection as it did at the dilution ratios recommended. There's no way we'd have used a standard petroleum 2-stroke oil at those ratios.
These days I think most synthetics are pretty close in performance -- but I'm still reluctant to use the old big-name dino-oils.
When I ran out of "known quality" 2-stroke oil for my lawn-mower, I bought a liter of Valvoline 4-stroke mower oil. Before I'd used half of it my mower was stuffed. The piston and rings were badly scuffed in a matter of 10 hours running or less. This was after nearly a decade of reliable operation on Castrol's dino-2stroke oil.
I should have know better -- the thin blue Valvoline just didn't look like it was a good oil (when compared to the much thicker Castrol). I wouldn't risk a model gasser engine to anything but the best oil I can afford.
-----------
Let's see if I got this figgered out right - you have a ratty, worn out, ten year old mower that blows up when Valvoline had the misfortune of being the last oil put in the crankcase. So now it is Valvoline's fault. Right?
Couldn't it just be that the mower was completely consumed during the previous ten years and Valvoline ended up S.O.O.L.? <G>
Ed Cregger