ORIGINAL: skulboep
Alright so I'm beginning building my 3rd plane (Sig Four Star 60 ARF) and after searching the forums for a couple days I have discovered a trend that I thought was supposedly a BAD idea: overpowering an aircraft. Now I'm not talking about going up an engine size if one lives at high altitudes in order to compensate for the lower pressures and decreased performance, I'm talking about strapping 1.20-sized 4 stroke into a 40-sized aircraft and running an extremely low pitch prop. Every instruction manual that I've ever read also cautions about overpowering an aircraft, claiming that the aircraft can become unstable in flight, the firewall can become weak, and if no catastrophe actually happens in flight, the warantee will at least be voided. However, in looking for an engine to pair with my Four Star 60 ARF, I've become interested in Super Tigre's line, especially the .75 2-stroke (a .75 engine in a .60-sized plane sounds pretty good, right?). According to many forums, most pilots that fly this plane recommend the Super Tigre 90 over the 75, claiming the 75 is barely enough engine (furthermore the 90 is has the exact same weight as the 75, meaning that it's performance increase over the 75 is probably pretty dramatic). How can this be, especially if Sig claims that the plane is a 60-sized plane? A 90 sounds insane!!! Do you guys have any experience with a particular engine in this plane or about the topic of overpowering in general? Let me know what you think! Thanks!!!
If I was in your position, I would put on a .91 4 stroke. But if you wanted to stick to the annoying whine of a 2 stroke (jk) then I would personally go with the 90, if the weight penalty isn't much more. I know that in the last plane I purchased, I got a .91 Magnum 4 stroke, becuase it only weighs 1 oz more than a .70, but has more power, and would suit more airplanes. So it is all up to you, and what you will fly the engine in in the future... I don't think the bigger one would overpower it too bad, if you keept he rpm's in a decent range, but still propped down. Even if you have to trim down full throttle a little, it is better than having too little power (not that the 70 would be too little though...) I hope that helps,
Scott