RCU Forums - View Single Post - New IJMC rules.
View Single Post
Old 01-23-2008 | 01:47 PM
  #22  
Shui's Avatar
Shui
My Feedback: (2)
 
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 447
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
From: Heathrow, FL
Default RE: New IJMC rules.

ORIGINAL: Gordon Mc
Just curious … unless there is a problem whereby most competitors don’t know how to install and configure gyros, why would those who think they are being beaten by a gyro not just install gyros in THEIR models in order to re-establish a level playing field ?

In other words, if “a good pilot with a gyro is very difficult to beat”, but you put 20 of the best pilots with gyros together, they are still gonna come out ranked 1 -> 20 somehow, right ? What causes that ranking, and how much does that process and results-set differ compared to when those exact same 20 best pilots compete without the gyro ?

That’s not sarcasm BTW, I really want to understand.

I realise that the gyro smoothes out the flight in order to make it look better, but there again, so can e.g. expo - and I haven’t heard any suggestions that all competitors must fly without expo, rates, flight modes, mixing, or a host of other common techniques that the purist could argue are obscuring some aspect of a pilot’s flying skills by helping to mask imperfections that might otherwise show up in his flying. Why is a gyro (a NON-RUDDER gyro, at that), so much more of a threat than any of the other techniques that are in common use ?

Gordon
Gordon,

A gyro inputs the control for you before you even realize you needed to correct. Exponential softens the control input which still must be applied by the pilot.

Granted, if the top 20 all have gyro's, things will still work out with 1-20th placing. What I'm getting at is to make the competition more difficult, to show true skill. I'd admit, flying with gyro's was very nice, made everything look great, but I'd still rather they be eliminated. I mean, the competition is about 2 things - static, and flying. Let's not take the fun/adventure out of the flying part!

The only thing I think the gyro's do for the competition is make the presentation much better overall, which is great for the competition, but I feel it softens the skill level necessary for the pilots in some respects. Maybe I'm way off base, but it's just my opinion on it.

And Dave - I agree with you completely on the landings!!!! Even many of the take-off's seemed too short to me.