Don't rule out the Maxx because of what you've been reading about the engine problems. The Maxx and Savage are BOTH very good trucks. Which one is right for you depends on which performance aspects are most important to you. If you want a larger truck with unmatched durability, good handling, and excellent ground clearance, go with the Savage. If you want a slightly smaller truck with blazing acceleration and top speed, decent handling, and an endless supply of aftermarket parts, go with the Maxx. Chances of you getting a Maxx with a finicky engine are about 50/50. Some folks have been able to get rid of the problem, some haven't.