Robo
do you read the posts here before making comments on the posters?
Nice snip job on the soundbite, but lets see that bite in context:
Is what the club is doing wrong?
If it is not, lets just tell Muncie about the conflict.... or is the plan to hide what the club is doing from Muncie?
There is no need to hide if it is not wrong
Know what, maybe I should shoot an email off to Muncie about this known conflict.... I mean, unless someone thinks I shouldnt for some reason. Surely somebody could explain to us all why we shouldnt tell Muncie about a club flying with a known freq conflict.
Shut down the club? Where, how?
I very clearly pointed out that in the case that the club is not violating any muncie rules, they have nothing to fear from Muncie.
Most folks of an
Innocent Until Proven Guilty mindset would say folks shoulnt live in fear of the bosses knowing what they are doing.... cause they presuming most folks are not doing anything wrong. Are you assuming there is some reason that if Muncie knew what was going on they would shutdown the club? Hows that even possible if we assume or declare the club to be in the right?
The only way I can see the threat of telling the Muncie what is going on to be a threat to shutdown the club,
would be to assume/deduce the club is in violation of Muncie rules so direly that a shutdown is in order.
Is that your stand?
That the club is so flagrantly violating Muncies rules that they would get shutdown if we dont keep it hushhush and hidden from our own org?
I asked, you state.
There is a difference. What I said was there is also a case where they have no reason to fear a shutdown: What they are doing dont violate Muncie rules. Why are you assuming/deducing that is not the case? Why are you not thinking Muncie will give them the thumbs up on the matter and have no reason to shut them down. I said that was wholely possibleyet you doscounted the possibility of their innocence.
Robo, your presumption of guilt in the matter kinda indicates you think they are breaking the rules you have presumed them guilty of.... how else could Muncie knowing what is going on cause a shutdown. Interesting how you are now so Anti-AMA Anti-Club that you presume such greivous violations of the poor club. I notice threads recently have you making slights and anti-ama biased posts... maybe your DVP shoud give you a talking to about dis'ing the org in public like that.
Robo, again, have you read this thread before searching for soundbites?
Who said I wanted the club shut down?
I very obviously said what I percieved the Perfect world solution would be to not have the club shutdown:
It's amazing how the Anti-club, anti-AMA sentiments come to light. Are you two licking your chops and drooling at the prospect of an established club loosing their flying site?
seems you totally missed where I described what I would like to see-
In a perfect world the county would step in, be the "bad guy" and resolve the situation
No, the clubbers make friends with the rogues rather than ama haters
and get a sharing agreement and have their friends remind other new guys about interference.
Why is a win-win friendship & sharing with fellow aeromodelers not even an ideal for you... is it so alien for you to get along and make friends even when there is a common hobby
I paint a picture of sharing freqs with friends and everyone being happy,
and you spin that into me wanting clubs shutdown.
Please stop painting your hate and assumption of club guilt onto my posts.[8D]
If you are done attacking the posters, can we get back to discussing the topic.
Jim
You forgot to tell Liberator he was way off base by taking your post seriously too.
<That is kinda tounge in cheek, incase you couldnt tell by text,
..of course, I ended the joke with a smiley so folks wouldnt take it too seriously.
We can do that, if you didnt you know.>