Well, I finally got around to comparing the 17x8 Scimitar to the 17x8 Menz.

Visually, the Scimitar is a beautiful prop with it's curved lines.

Performance-wise I was hard pressed to tell the difference between the two on my Saito 1.80 equipped ultimate. They seemed very simular to my limited experience. Same vertical, same pull, I can only hover poorly, but seemed about the same.

If I had to guess I will find that the Menz has a little better downline braking due to the wider profile, but not much.

For me these two props are a tossup.