Didja try this one? It's the Rustoleum professional high performance enamel in the silver rattle cans. Got it from True Value. It says Safety Red so I think you tried a different Safety Red than this one. I can vouch for how well it matches the red oracover on my BH T-28. The edge between the cowl and Oracover on the nose is hardly discernible...of course this is a pic, but in person, this is perfect to me, and I am anal, lol. Jon