Apparently it was a combination of a few different things.

One of the motors was bad so I replaced them both. I had to adjust one of the settings on the 3-in-1. Checked all the wires, unhooked everything and hooked it all back in to make sure I had a good connection, and had to rearrange the wires inside the canopy to get them away from the servos and motors.

I do think my receiver may be bad (or going bad). Even after rebinding Im having trouble somewhere between the remote and heli. I have to turn the remote on, hookup the battery to the heli. Wait a few seconds for it to register (the servos then work) but in order to use the throttle I have to turn the remote back off and on again and let it rebind a second time. After that everything is A-OK.

For now, im just super thankful to be able to get it back in the air. Its a crappy feeling sitting here looking at it just sitting there =)