Bud Weber's Sequel,

Question: Does a modeler want to reproduce the most accurate reproduction or does a modeler want to recreate the "flying characteristics" of the original model, which may be lighter, as accurate and more readily reproduced by the average modeler?

What do you mean?

Example #1: I want to reproduce an EXACT replica of Bud's Sequel. As a competition modeler I recognize that Bud would have used the finest and lightest hand selected balsa wood, sanded, whittled every wing tip, fuselage block, fin and rudder to save weight based on his choice to use mostly blocks of bals wood. A silkspun coverite, laquer primer and dope finish was chosen.

Limitations reproducing example #1: Wood selection is very critical for the fuselage, fin and rudder wood AND every effort will need to be made to save or 1 - 4 ounces will be mysteriously be UN-added during construction. The finish is simple, fragile, marginably able to handle moisture and requires great skill to apply and be light.

Example #2: I want to create the "flying characteristics" of the Sequel. The modern kit manufacturer recognizes the limitations in example #1 AND desires that the kit be easier for the least skilled modeler to reproduce with a high degree of accuracy. The modern manufacturer choses to simplify construction, re-engineer structures to create a lighter and more rigid structure. The builder may also choose to use a modern film covering as well.

Limitations reproducing example #2: Easier for the average modeler. Easy to find materials. Simple covering process. Longer lasting more consistent model due to more rigid construction.

Okay, you made the point: "The more modern the kit, the easier it will be for the average modeler to create or re-create the flying qualities of the original model."

The Sequel issue...Bud chose to use 3/4" blocks of balsa to make the fin and rudder. According to the construction article "...his kids liked the balsa shavings...and it could be built up..." I talked to Dan (Laser Tech) about this issue. I said that a built up fin and rudder would lighter, stronger, remain straighter longer and I will not need to buy $40 worth of wood to get a few precious pieces of 3/4" stock that is even close to Bud's competition model weight (my goal).

Long story short...It is my opinion that a purist will scratch build a model using the original plans...great, I admire your skills and abilities. The rest of us (90%+) want to "experience" the characteristic of the original model, removing all of the known variables like weight, ease of accuracy... using modern techniques.

A classic kit reproduction manufacturer may create an "exact" reproduction and other/s may create the simplest, 100% accurate without using different materials and techniques.

NO ONE METHOD IS BETTER OR WORSE.

Personally, I have a split personality. I have selected different kits for my different goals and expectations.


Rusty Dose
Team Futaba
Team YS Parts and Service

P.S. I generally try to edit spelling errors, confusing sentences or to simplify message.