RE: Safety Violations
Doc,
I didn't get that KC was directing any of this at you directly at all. I think he was merely pointing out something he had seen as an example and indicative of a wider problem. I think he explained his view politely and clearly. I also think it is pretty clear that your flight had extenuating circumstances, but that KC still would have had you fly again. Not to say that you are not safe, just that he - in his opinion would make doubly sure before he signs off on anything.
On the topic of safety...
Now back to club rules and bad fliers. I agree that the AMA rules seem fair and that cash penalties would cause serious issues. I also agree that any actions taken should be documented. One would hope that the safety officer is impartial in their decision to reprimand individuals. In our club we offer training classes, I would suggest that people who are repeat offenders be forced to complete a training course before having field privileges reinstated.
-Brian