I really don't go by what those magazines do and say. They are always biased one way or another depending on who paid them the most and sponsor them the most. Obviously Dodge doesn't. Any ways, I like the Challenger for the way it looks and feels. I've had the chance to ride and drive quite a few of them. From the base model to the SRT 8. To me they are much more than just a muscle car. I like the room in them. Only people that can fit into the Mustang are short people with no legs. There just isn't any room in the back seat. The Camaro has more room in the back seat than the predecessor. It has a lot more hp and torque but, the car weighs so much more than it's predecessor. The Challenger is even heavier than the Camaro. It has a little bit more or less hp and torque. I love the look of it. I like the look of the Camaro. The new Mustang is ugly. WTH was Ford thinking. They are way under powered also. A buddy of mine has one and I just really don't like the look of it. In 2005 when they came out they were good looking except for the room. None. This is all stock of course. They all have their pros and cons. I just love the way the Challenger looks. I can't help it. I won't turn down a Camaro or a Mustang.