"We have a definitive answer from the AMA."

great, lets hear the how many million then


"Maybe if you want those numbers that concern you so greatly you should ask the AMA comptroller"
wait... didnt you just say we just got the answer?

Cause you linked in post#1 a thread where I asked AMA about the member cost,
as clearly evidenced on the first page of the thread
by me having to explain to the griping folks what I wanted the info for.... and it was explained that it was for later use in debating Optional MA. Thats the little piece of info we got from AMA, individual cost to member, not the actual sum of how many millions MA is making or losing.

YOU are claiming it puts the MA financing to rest- the AMA guy didnt say that & I didnt say that.
You make the claim it is put to rest
but you cant answer the most basic of accounting question on MA: How much in & how much out.

If you cant answer that for starters,
then obviously it hasnt been put to rest at all.

You made the claim, and you are refusing to support your statement at the most basic level.
To wit:
I hypothesize that MA is only getting $25k transfered in vis Gray$18 from the $7milDues
If that is true, then MA is still losing a million dollars itself.

Well, Robo, does my hypothesis hold water
... or do you have some other Gray18 amount in the millions that you think we should use?
According to your thread topic, its been solved, so lets have it.