You are really reading too much into this. While you can't really go wrong either way, my recommendation that you stick with mode 2. At the stage that you are, I believe you should think about convenience and ability to get help to become better, faster, and not necessarily think about what would work best if/when you are at the competition stage.

Here's a tip: start with mode 2 and improve to the point that you can compete - this will take you some time. At that point, if you truly feel that mode 2 is a hindrance to your success and advancement, then consider switching. Yes, yes, much more difficult to switch at a later stage, but chances are that you will not feel the need to change, and meanwhile, you would have benefited from all the help your club members can give you.

If you choose mode 2, I'll bet you will not feel the need to change later on. Good luck either way.