ORIGINAL: LNEWQBAN
First, I would return that drill jig to TroyBuilt, asking for a refund plus a compensation for the damaged propeller.
If they stated that the drill jig was good for your engine and it was not, THEY have a problem.
I was wondering why nobody brought this up. So far the thread has been about fixing a prop that looks very much like the vendor's fault. Have them take care of it.