Airliner finlets???
#1
Thread Starter
Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 56
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kalaheo, HI
I have been wondering how all those little fins on the top of wings function .
I assume its to direct airflow in various directions to create more lift.
Aloha Les
I assume its to direct airflow in various directions to create more lift.
Aloha Les
#2
The little ones that are about 1 inch square or so and stick up?
Those are turbulators. They are too small to direct the air. The idea is to pay a small drag penalty and turbulate the airflow so it'll stick to the wing's surface better and delay the stall during the nasty parts of landings and takeoffs when the speed is low and the lift needs are high.
Those are turbulators. They are too small to direct the air. The idea is to pay a small drag penalty and turbulate the airflow so it'll stick to the wing's surface better and delay the stall during the nasty parts of landings and takeoffs when the speed is low and the lift needs are high.
#3
Senior Member
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 354
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: opononi, NEW ZEALAND
There has been some pretty good discussion about this just in recent times.
If you do a search on "winglets" and "tip plates" down this board you should pick up on most.
Very interesting topic I think. Been playing with them (with some success) for about the past ten years. Can't even now that I am sure one way or the other (for or against).
The theory is to reduce the size of the tip vortex thus increasing efficiency.
and what Bruce said, more so than me 
If you do a search on "winglets" and "tip plates" down this board you should pick up on most.
Very interesting topic I think. Been playing with them (with some success) for about the past ten years. Can't even now that I am sure one way or the other (for or against).
The theory is to reduce the size of the tip vortex thus increasing efficiency.
and what Bruce said, more so than me 
#4
Thread Starter
Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 56
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kalaheo, HI
Thanks guys ,
I am new to this hobby and appreciate the input , Thinking about building my next plane ( # 3 ). Possibly a gas Spad.
Aloha, Les
I am new to this hobby and appreciate the input , Thinking about building my next plane ( # 3 ). Possibly a gas Spad.
Aloha, Les
#5
Senior Member
My Feedback: (12)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Madison, WI,
The turbulators referred to above are actually called vortex generators. They have been used for many years. They were on some early jet fighters on the wings and also on the fuselage near the horizontal stabilizer. The B-720 and B707 had many of them on the wings. As I remember there were over 50 on each wing. They were added to prevent spanwise airflow.
#6
Senior Member
There's a surprising amount of span-wise flow even at high speeds occuring behind the local shock position.
We experimented with generators on the Tristar. Typical flow patterns looked like these..
Didn't install them ultimately. A combination of NIH and looks bad..
We experimented with generators on the Tristar. Typical flow patterns looked like these..
Didn't install them ultimately. A combination of NIH and looks bad..
#7
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: West Sussex, UNITED KINGDOM
Its not just the big airliners that have them, we got a Beechcraft Duke in the hangar right now ( piston engine twin,pressurised ) which is smothered in vortex generators, along the wing and up the fin. Apparently also used on old transports like the Beverly which had a pretty much square end to the fuselage. The vortex generators actually cause the laminar airflow to curve further round the rear boxy end than would have if it had no vortex generators. This delays the separation of the airflow from the fuselage thereby reducing the turbulent airflow which causes drag.
Sean
What next, Kucheman carrots
Sean
What next, Kucheman carrots
#9
That's an amazing pic Paul. Interesting that the tufts in the first shot are flowing OUTWARD. I would guess into a localized separation bubble that was eliminated by the vortex gen's.
And what's NIH mean?
And what's NIH mean?
#14
Senior Member
ISTR one of the reasons we didn't adopt the vortex generators was they are an admission that wing is designed wrong.
That's one of the reasons they show up on planes which entered service without them, they're fixes.. relatively inexpensive though.
Another thing we tried was the McDD "engine ears"' those vanes on the wing engines on the DC-10.
Although there was a benefit to the stall speed, it wasn't sufficient to warrant purchasing the license to use them.. and NIH (Not Invented Here)
MOF, when we tested them, we made them out of 1/2" Lexan, so they wouldn't be visible from the ground.
Interesting flow patterns off them at the stall...
I have some film footage around here someplace...
That's one of the reasons they show up on planes which entered service without them, they're fixes.. relatively inexpensive though.
Another thing we tried was the McDD "engine ears"' those vanes on the wing engines on the DC-10.
Although there was a benefit to the stall speed, it wasn't sufficient to warrant purchasing the license to use them.. and NIH (Not Invented Here)
MOF, when we tested them, we made them out of 1/2" Lexan, so they wouldn't be visible from the ground.
Interesting flow patterns off them at the stall...
I have some film footage around here someplace...
#15
Originally posted by Tall Paul
ISTR one of the reasons we didn't adopt the vortex generators was they are an admission that wing is designed wrong...
ISTR one of the reasons we didn't adopt the vortex generators was they are an admission that wing is designed wrong...

I do love the fact that even with all the windtunnels and other research tools available in the end you were still taping tufts of yarn to the planes and flying them in the "real" world.
#18
Member
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Grand Forks, ND
VG's are used on some multi-engined light twins to lower Vmca while those on some large transport aircraft may be used to delay separation, decrease drag at high transonic speeds. They tend to reduce the magnitude of the shock wave produced at Mforce divergence. Interesting how they work at low and high speeds!
#20
Member
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Grand Forks, ND
Vortex generators (vg's) turbulate (add energy) while fences reduce spanwise flow by redirecting (or excluding the low-pressure area on the outboard/downwing side). Another type of device seen is the vortelon. Invisible at high speeds, it adds energy to the flow at low-speeds by taking advantage of the spanwise flow.





