Dave Patrick Big Ultimate
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, CA OK,
Just ordered a DP Ultimate in blue. I was wanting to see if anyone has put something like a Moki 1.8 or 2.10 on one of these babies. I am planning on putting a Webra Bully 2.2 glow. I think it will be radical with power ,but that's what a throttle is for. Engine looks to fit just right and the Bully is known for being light and powerful for its size. Weight of engine and muffler is 48 oz.
Comments anyone ?
Thx
Don
Comments anyone ?
Thx
Don
#2
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Lenexa,
KS
I'm finishing one up with a OS 160FX in it right now. People hover these things with Saito 150-180's. From what I've seen building the plane the airframe will need considerable reinforcement to the front for that motor (probably replace the firewall) and you're gonna have to move something to the tail to balance out that monster on the front. Overall your looking at making a 10-11 lb plane into a 12-14lb one but hey if all your gonna do is sit it in the vertical position and hover it all day you'll be glad you went with that monster otherwise your gonna hurt the plane's general flying performance somewhat.
#9
Thread Starter

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, CA OK,
OK, so I'm taking some flack on this. I did a little digging and here is what I came up with.
OS 160 3.7 HP weight 32 oz w/o muff
YS 140 3.2 HP W 32 oz w/o muff
Saito 180 2.8 HP w around 32 oz
Moki 1.80 4.10 HP w 41 oz w/ muff
Moki 2.10 4.95 HP w 46 oz w/muff
So, If people have been putting a Moki 1.8 on these and other DP planes why am I way out of the ball park. My Bully should be comparable to the Moki 1.8 and only weight 7 oz more.
Mendes is right. I wish the thing was a little bigger but I have no other Ultimates to choose from.
Comments?
OS 160 3.7 HP weight 32 oz w/o muff
YS 140 3.2 HP W 32 oz w/o muff
Saito 180 2.8 HP w around 32 oz
Moki 1.80 4.10 HP w 41 oz w/ muff
Moki 2.10 4.95 HP w 46 oz w/muff
So, If people have been putting a Moki 1.8 on these and other DP planes why am I way out of the ball park. My Bully should be comparable to the Moki 1.8 and only weight 7 oz more.
Mendes is right. I wish the thing was a little bigger but I have no other Ultimates to choose from.
Comments?
#10
Thread Starter

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, CA OK,
Look at the TOC planes. What about the power to weight ratio on those things. That's about as radical as it gets. We see their example and want our budget stuff to be able to do the same. I watched Sean McMurtry grow up here in OKC and got to see him fly his TOC stuff many times in practice. Incredible performance. His dad Mike who runs the LHS still flys the big stuff, in fact he just finished the new 1/3 H9 Suk. and is using the new 3W100 to power it. Another friend has the same set up and it rockets out of a hover.
Just because you have a large reserve of power does not mean you can not stay within the envelope of the aircraft.
Just because you have a large reserve of power does not mean you can not stay within the envelope of the aircraft.
#11
I think I have a 3W 100 twin that should fit nicely, If you do not mind the cylinders hanging out of the sides of the cowl. Do you have enough clearence for a 28" prop?
Welcome to RCU worldmodelnut!
Welcome to RCU worldmodelnut!
#12
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Lenexa,
KS
The Ultimate is quite a bit smaller than the Extra 330L or the Edge 540T and Dave admits the Moki 1.80 would work on the Extra and Edge but is WAY overkill on the Ultimate. Yeah a lot of power is wonderful but This 2.2 on the Patrick Ultimate is the equivalent of a putting a 200cc Twin on a 33% plane. Yeah I'll have kick ass power but at the cost of wing loading. Hovering is cool but if your looking for TOC like plane in a smaller package loading it down with a bigger than neccesary motor is not the answer, you need to balance weight with power.
#13
Thread Starter

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego, CA OK,
OK,
How about this. I have a G-23 Glow. I have trimmed the weight down from 37.8 oz to 33 oz by removing excess case, rear shaft output, etc. I run 5% oil and 15% nitro on this engine and it really humms. I had it on a 14.75 LBS H9 Taylorcraft and I pulled it around with no problem. I can turn a APC 16 X 8 @ 8800 all day and the engine only has 1.5 gallon through it. Now here is my thinking. I am close to the weight of a Saito 180 with the power of a 150+. If I can keep the weight of the plane to say 11 LBS I would think that it will haul the crap out of it. I like the pump carb because I can put my tank near the CG. I still might experiment with the G-23 by putting a Delorto carb on an seeing if I get more RPM and better throttle response.
Comments?
How about this. I have a G-23 Glow. I have trimmed the weight down from 37.8 oz to 33 oz by removing excess case, rear shaft output, etc. I run 5% oil and 15% nitro on this engine and it really humms. I had it on a 14.75 LBS H9 Taylorcraft and I pulled it around with no problem. I can turn a APC 16 X 8 @ 8800 all day and the engine only has 1.5 gallon through it. Now here is my thinking. I am close to the weight of a Saito 180 with the power of a 150+. If I can keep the weight of the plane to say 11 LBS I would think that it will haul the crap out of it. I like the pump carb because I can put my tank near the CG. I still might experiment with the G-23 by putting a Delorto carb on an seeing if I get more RPM and better throttle response.
Comments?
#15

My Feedback: (5)
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: parlin,
NJ
I think we are looking at this thing the wrong way by talking about putting larger engines in the ultimate. I sent Dave Patrick a letter about giving the market place a larger ultimate. It is clear to many of us that a larger ulitmate is needed. Lets look at the playing field there are no ultimate arfs for a 2.4 to 4.2 size out there. In this size you find the majority of your gas engines especially the 3.2.. What I am talking about is something with a 70"-80" ws. This would be the perfect size. Here is a guy Dave Patrick with a ARF Ultimate voted the best ARF in the land by MAN.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
#16
Senior Member
My Feedback: (7)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Atlanta
I have a Saito 180 on my DP Ulty....weight ready to go is 11lbs. It has way more then enough power....I think a Saito 150 would be plenty. Keep it light....a light plane flys much better.
#17
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,914
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Canton,
MI
Originally posted by McCoy
I think we are looking at this thing the wrong way by talking about putting larger engines in the ultimate. I sent Dave Patrick a letter about giving the market place a larger ultimate. It is clear to many of us that a larger ulitmate is needed. Lets look at the playing field there are no ultimate arfs for a 2.4 to 4.2 size out there. In this size you find the majority of your gas engines especially the 3.2.. What I am talking about is something with a 70"-80" ws. This would be the perfect size. Here is a guy Dave Patrick with a ARF Ultimate voted the best ARF in the land by MAN.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
I think we are looking at this thing the wrong way by talking about putting larger engines in the ultimate. I sent Dave Patrick a letter about giving the market place a larger ultimate. It is clear to many of us that a larger ulitmate is needed. Lets look at the playing field there are no ultimate arfs for a 2.4 to 4.2 size out there. In this size you find the majority of your gas engines especially the 3.2.. What I am talking about is something with a 70"-80" ws. This would be the perfect size. Here is a guy Dave Patrick with a ARF Ultimate voted the best ARF in the land by MAN.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
#20
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Originally posted by McCoy
I think we are looking at this thing the wrong way by talking about putting larger engines in the ultimate. I sent Dave Patrick a letter about giving the market place a larger ultimate. It is clear to many of us that a larger ulitmate is needed. Lets look at the playing field there are no ultimate arfs for a 2.4 to 4.2 size out there. In this size you find the majority of your gas engines especially the 3.2.. What I am talking about is something with a 70"-80" ws. This would be the perfect size. Here is a guy Dave Patrick with a ARF Ultimate voted the best ARF in the land by MAN.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
I think we are looking at this thing the wrong way by talking about putting larger engines in the ultimate. I sent Dave Patrick a letter about giving the market place a larger ultimate. It is clear to many of us that a larger ulitmate is needed. Lets look at the playing field there are no ultimate arfs for a 2.4 to 4.2 size out there. In this size you find the majority of your gas engines especially the 3.2.. What I am talking about is something with a 70"-80" ws. This would be the perfect size. Here is a guy Dave Patrick with a ARF Ultimate voted the best ARF in the land by MAN.
You would think he would be interested in producing something like this. I would of thought he would of made a bigger ultimate before he produce the .40 version.(remember he sells completly out of the 1.20 ultimates that he orders). He could sell them on a special order bases limited # he already has the drawings and knowleged to do so. It could be priced around $500.00-$600.00 something that we all could live with. I feel cheated that a company that we have supported with our money may stifle our abilities to move forward. I think all of us who love to fly ultimate should email him and let them know, I've already led the charge.
You feel cheated? Don't. If you want to move forward get a 1/3 Hangar 9 ARF. To feel that Dave Patrick is responsible for not allowing you to move forward in the hobby is absurd. A small company can only do so much, I would rather see them put more time in researching and developing the model than to have them rush it out to market before it is truly ready.




