Another retract question
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,647
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: North Port, FL
I know this has been discussed many of times beforebut i've been searching on here for directions on how to convert my H9 P-51 60 retracts stock wireto 3/16" but I can't find them are there any? I know I need to drill out the gears? And will need to bend the ends where the wheels go. What about the collars? Do they get drilled out as well?
Any help would be great andpics would be awesome. lol Can I get the 3/16 rod at HomeDepot?
I came in for a landing and was floating along nice and slow just about to touch downwhen my right retract snapped off when it hit a fire ant hill. Minor damage to the fuse and wing and an easy fix.
Bummer! Was hoping to fly all day....
Thanks
Any help would be great andpics would be awesome. lol Can I get the 3/16 rod at HomeDepot?
I came in for a landing and was floating along nice and slow just about to touch downwhen my right retract snapped off when it hit a fire ant hill. Minor damage to the fuse and wing and an easy fix.
Bummer! Was hoping to fly all day....
Thanks
#2

My Feedback: (221)
ORIGINAL: drube
I know this has been discussed many of times before but i've been searching on here for directions on how to convert my H9 P-51 60 retracts stock wire to 3/16'' but I can't find them are there any? I know I need to drill out the gears? And will need to bend the ends where the wheels go. What about the collars? Do they get drilled out as well?
Any help would be great and pics would be awesome. lol Can I get the 3/16 rod at HomeDepot?
I came in for a landing and was floating along nice and slow just about to touch down when my right retract snapped off when it hit a fire ant hill. Minor damage to the fuse and wing and an easy fix.
Bummer! Was hoping to fly all day....
Thanks[img][/img]
I know this has been discussed many of times before but i've been searching on here for directions on how to convert my H9 P-51 60 retracts stock wire to 3/16'' but I can't find them are there any? I know I need to drill out the gears? And will need to bend the ends where the wheels go. What about the collars? Do they get drilled out as well?
Any help would be great and pics would be awesome. lol Can I get the 3/16 rod at HomeDepot?
I came in for a landing and was floating along nice and slow just about to touch down when my right retract snapped off when it hit a fire ant hill. Minor damage to the fuse and wing and an easy fix.
Bummer! Was hoping to fly all day....
Thanks[img][/img]
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix,
AZ
The wire from HD is quite soft and will bend. I just converted my retracts using HD wire so I know first hand. I should probably change it and use the music wire but with all the work I have done I will give it a try. Will maiden the "new" retracts this week. Also agree about the wheel collars. Buy new 3/16.
Also use adjustable 3/16 axles available at you LHS. Forget about trying to bend the wire.
Jim W
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 285
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Mount Juliet,
TN
Hey Jim,
What if your HD wire retracts bend on take off? Keep a sharp eye out. They may not retract properly and a struggling retract servo could drain your flight battery.
Tom
What if your HD wire retracts bend on take off? Keep a sharp eye out. They may not retract properly and a struggling retract servo could drain your flight battery.
Tom
#5
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Yea Jim, that wire will not work. Sorry to have to tell you, but after all that work, you'll have to make them again with spring steel (Music) wire, but at least it was not for nothing... Since you made one set already, you now have experience
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix,
AZ
Tom
Yes I am aware of retracts binding if the strut is bent. Not a good thing. The HD wire is soft and will bend if it is stressed by a bad landing. It will take a reasonable amount side load etc before it will bend out of shape. There is still a lot of movement in the plastic retract even with the heavier wire and this should absorb some of the stress on the wire. We will see what happens on a few flights this week. Not a big problem to make new struts with music wire if there is a problem. The major work of modifying the retract is done. Needless to say I will post my results. I have done a lot of retract installations over the years and my problems have been minimal. I have a set up using a seperate battery for the retracts but have not used it in this setup as yet. One other suggestion is to use an amp meter when setting them up to make sure there is no bind in the up and down cycle of the servo. The HiTeck retract servo is a bear for punishment and is highly recomended. One other thing. Am using A123 3400 RX battery
Jim W
#7
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix,
AZ
Hey Mike
Picked up your post after my long winded post. Could you please elaborate on your wire problem. I have static tested this thing and thought it would work. Please give a few details it would be much appreciated.
Jim W
#8
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
If you fly from pavement, they may last a for a few sorties, but if you fly from grass, you can pack it in now.
I reviewed an ARF once that used cold-rolled steel instead of spring steel once. This plane did not have retracts, just a standard trike setup. After only 3 takeoffs and landings, the gear were bent so badly that the props were touching the ground - and they were NOT bad takeoffs or landings.
I straightened them and took off again. When the plane got down, I inspected them and saw a major change in the shape. I even commented then that, "It's a good thing this thing doesn't have retracts or the wheels would have never made it into the wheel wells - and if they did, they wouldn't have come back out!"
Just running those wires through the grass on takeoff was enough to bend them considerably. Even running spring steel wires through grass is enough that you'll want to check them periodically, but with cold-rolled steel, you'll be lucky to get one flight in without them getting stuck.
I reviewed an ARF once that used cold-rolled steel instead of spring steel once. This plane did not have retracts, just a standard trike setup. After only 3 takeoffs and landings, the gear were bent so badly that the props were touching the ground - and they were NOT bad takeoffs or landings.
I straightened them and took off again. When the plane got down, I inspected them and saw a major change in the shape. I even commented then that, "It's a good thing this thing doesn't have retracts or the wheels would have never made it into the wheel wells - and if they did, they wouldn't have come back out!"
Just running those wires through the grass on takeoff was enough to bend them considerably. Even running spring steel wires through grass is enough that you'll want to check them periodically, but with cold-rolled steel, you'll be lucky to get one flight in without them getting stuck.
#9
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix,
AZ
Mike
Thanks you much for the info. We do have asphalt for a runway. Your comments about grass is enlightning.
Haven't had a grass field since I left Ohio. Anyway I have mixed emotions about a soft strut. My instincts like the fact they will bend in the event of a hard landing rather than maybe ripping them out of the wing. I will pick up some "Music" wire and make up a set of struts. I will also use what I have and give it a try on asphalt and see what happens. Sometimes my "hard nose" gets in the way of reality but a couple of flights will tell the story.
Thanks again for your comments. They are appreciated
Jim W
#10
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Jim, by all means, try it out. But before you take off, note how the wheels sit in the wheel wells - then check them again after a flight. Check them after the first few flights and see how they are holding up.
My educated guess is: They won't last very long before the wheels start to get stuck.
But if they work... Good for you!
My educated guess is: They won't last very long before the wheels start to get stuck.
But if they work... Good for you!
#11
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 1,052
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Bend,
OR
drube,
I did an upgrade to my H9 AT6 landing gear to 3/16" wire. I called Robart and got the wire that was already bent for an AT6 for $12. They were very helpful..........call Robart and see if they have wires for the P51.....if so you will have no problems, they were the right length for my model and only required very carefully enlarging the holes for a press fit of the new wires. This is a common mod on the AT6 and maybe it can be for your P51.
Andy
I did an upgrade to my H9 AT6 landing gear to 3/16" wire. I called Robart and got the wire that was already bent for an AT6 for $12. They were very helpful..........call Robart and see if they have wires for the P51.....if so you will have no problems, they were the right length for my model and only required very carefully enlarging the holes for a press fit of the new wires. This is a common mod on the AT6 and maybe it can be for your P51.
Andy
#12
Thread Starter

Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,647
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: North Port, FL
Thanks.
Got off work today went to my LHS and picked up some 3/16" music wire and collars. Fixed! That was easy! I need to check the CG and i'm good to go. I can tell it's alot stronger andcan't wait to fly it.
Also use adjustable 3/16 axles available at you LHS. Forget about trying to bend the wire.
Thanks for all your help.
</p>
#13

My Feedback: (221)
ORIGINAL: drube
Thanks.
Got off work today went to my LHS and picked up some 3/16'' music wire and collars. Fixed! That was easy! I need to check the CG and i'm good to go. I can tell it's alot stronger and can't wait to fly it.
Jim, Do by any chance have a link for those?
Thanks for all your help.
[img][/img] </p>
Thanks.
Got off work today went to my LHS and picked up some 3/16'' music wire and collars. Fixed! That was easy! I need to check the CG and i'm good to go. I can tell it's alot stronger and can't wait to fly it.
Also use adjustable 3/16 axles available at you LHS. Forget about trying to bend the wire.
Thanks for all your help.
[img][/img] </p>
#14
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Be sure to grind a flat on the strut to keep these from rotating
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...?&I=LXK183&P=7
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...?&I=LXK183&P=7



