flutter?
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,734
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Spring Hill,
FL
Take a piece of paper and hold it out your car window while you're driving. That's flutter. It is speed dependent and may be a moron flying a plane in a way not intended and may be a poor quality kit, but more often than not it's a sloppy control setup or flexible controls. Actually, the misusing the plane thing is pretty common too.
I'm one of those morons who likes to put my planes in terminal velocity power dives to see what happens. I've lost two elevators because of that. My controls are much better now and I still do the power dives, but I don't lose the planes any more.
I'm one of those morons who likes to put my planes in terminal velocity power dives to see what happens. I've lost two elevators because of that. My controls are much better now and I still do the power dives, but I don't lose the planes any more.
#5
Senior Member
My Feedback: (3)
SJM55! How are ya? The only thing that hasn't been mentioned is if your linkage isn't set high enough up on the control horn. It might be safe to say that if you are 3/4 of an inch up on the control horn, the linkage geometry will be able to hold the flap steady. If you are controlling your flap from one extreme end [like with some aileron setups] and the wood is too flimsy that can contribute to the problem. Not having sealed gaps can contribute. The cause can come from just one, or several contributing factors. The buzzing sound from extreme flutter is unmistakable. immediately throttle down and land. You can disintegrate the tiny plastic teeth on the servo gears in the blink of an eye. Unless you are disciplined enough to fly below flutter speed always, it's a good idea to try the simple fixes to eliminate the problem.
#6
Banned
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: gone,
Unfortunately... the geometry of the control linkages is only one factor in flutter control, and the distance from hinge line to clevice on the control horn needs to be larger as the aircraft becomes larger. (and some other factors can change what will work and what won't)
Do a search on Flutter, and you will find a LOT of threads discussing the ways to prevent it.
The most common thing to break first with flutter is the hinge, or the servo gears. I have seen aileron flutter rip a wing off of one aircraft.
Do a search on Flutter, and you will find a LOT of threads discussing the ways to prevent it.
The most common thing to break first with flutter is the hinge, or the servo gears. I have seen aileron flutter rip a wing off of one aircraft.
#7
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 4,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Laurel, MD,
There's control surface flutter (which, technically isn't actually called "flutter", but we all call it flutter anyway)
And there's flutter of the entire structure, the whole wing or stab fluttering or flexing due to the aerodynamic loads on it.
Lots of causes for both, and lots of things to do to try to stop it. And yes, it's nasty. I stripped an aileron servo while testing out a new combat design last season. I went from flying fine to having 0 aileron control in an instant, and it was a fairly shallow dive that did it.
And there's flutter of the entire structure, the whole wing or stab fluttering or flexing due to the aerodynamic loads on it.
Lots of causes for both, and lots of things to do to try to stop it. And yes, it's nasty. I stripped an aileron servo while testing out a new combat design last season. I went from flying fine to having 0 aileron control in an instant, and it was a fairly shallow dive that did it.
#8
Senior Member
In general, flutter is when an outside force stimulates a structure at its natural frequency. Any and all surfaces will flutter if excited at the proper frequency. When that happens, a small input can produce a large output, enough to tear the structure apart. Keeping contol rods ridged, stiff with no slop or spring back prevents the initial initialization. Building stiff and ridgid (but light) surfaces also helps prevent flutter from ever starting (this raises the natural frequency above the exciting frequency). The biggest cause for flutter initiation in models is sloppy hinges, soft control systems or flimsy structure. Hinge gap is seldom a cause of flutter although it does cause surface deflection to be less effective.
#9
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,734
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Spring Hill,
FL
ORIGINAL: Montague
There's control surface flutter (which, technically isn't actually called "flutter", but we all call it flutter anyway)
There's control surface flutter (which, technically isn't actually called "flutter", but we all call it flutter anyway)
#10
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 4,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Laurel, MD,
Oh, you would have to ask that. I don't remember.
I just call it flutter like 99% of all modelers. However, if you ask over on the aerodynamics forum, where guys can get really picky about exact terms for these things, you might get an answer.
More to the point, when you go searching for info on flutter in aerodynamic books and websites, they always are talking about the whole wing or stab fluttering around, they don't mention the control surface moving while the wing stays still.
But, really, who cares
.
I just call it flutter like 99% of all modelers. However, if you ask over on the aerodynamics forum, where guys can get really picky about exact terms for these things, you might get an answer.More to the point, when you go searching for info on flutter in aerodynamic books and websites, they always are talking about the whole wing or stab fluttering around, they don't mention the control surface moving while the wing stays still.
But, really, who cares
.
#11

My Feedback: (11)
ORIGINAL: Montague
they always are talking about the whole wing or stab fluttering around, they don't mention the control surface moving while the wing stays still.
they always are talking about the whole wing or stab fluttering around, they don't mention the control surface moving while the wing stays still.
#12
Senior Member
There is a video of the full size F 117 stealth at an airshow. When they showed it in slow motion the whole wing flapped about three times, like a bird, and disintegrated in about two frames.



