WHAT IS WING STALL?
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
In my schoolyard scale electric J-3 Cub plans it states "Contour sand the leading edge using the contour gauge provided. If left with sharp edge wing will stall."
A] I have a simple, if not ignorant, question: What is 'wing stall'?
B] Also I made the mistake of gluing the left panel wing tip flush with the tip rib bottom (flat on the building board) instead of off-center with the rib and centered with the leading edge. I filled the gaps nicely at the leading and trailing edge with scrap balsa but would like to know: I know I will have to do the same with the right wing panel but . . . will the slight displacement of the tips cause any significant difference in the flight or the tip's airfoil characteristics?
A] I have a simple, if not ignorant, question: What is 'wing stall'?
B] Also I made the mistake of gluing the left panel wing tip flush with the tip rib bottom (flat on the building board) instead of off-center with the rib and centered with the leading edge. I filled the gaps nicely at the leading and trailing edge with scrap balsa but would like to know: I know I will have to do the same with the right wing panel but . . . will the slight displacement of the tips cause any significant difference in the flight or the tip's airfoil characteristics?
#2
RCU Forum Manager/Admin
My Feedback: (9)
From Wikipedia
As the quote says, as stall is when the wing quits producing lift.
Ken
n aerodynamics, a stall is a sudden reduction in the lift forces generated by an airfoil. This most usually occurs when the critical angle of attack for the airfoil is exceeded.
Because stalls are most commonly discussed in connection with aviation, this article discusses stalls mainly as they relate to aircraft. In layman's terms, a stall in an aircraft is an event that causes the aircraft to drop suddenly (see the overview below).
Note that an aerodynamic stall does not mean that an aircraft's engines have stopped or that the aircraft has stopped moving.
Because stalls are most commonly discussed in connection with aviation, this article discusses stalls mainly as they relate to aircraft. In layman's terms, a stall in an aircraft is an event that causes the aircraft to drop suddenly (see the overview below).
Note that an aerodynamic stall does not mean that an aircraft's engines have stopped or that the aircraft has stopped moving.
Ken
#3
Wing stall simply means that the air flow over/under the wing is no longer providing the neccisary lift to keep the plane flying. For some reason (ask the aero dynamics guys) a sharp leading edge stalls at a higher speed than a more blunt LE. As far as your wing tips go. I'm not exactly sure what you mean but it would be hard to make it unflyable. Can you upload a picture?
#5
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
Here they are. Photos 1, 2 & 3 is how I glued'em on. Photos 4 & 5 are how it was supposed to be done. The plans did not show it very closely and by the time I looked more closely at it they were already glued (medium CA)
#6
Yes it will still fly just fine... My guess is that it's a little scale detail they added to the kit that only has a semi-scale wing anyway. The only reason anyone would know you goofed it would be because you told them
#7
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Ditto, but let me just take this opportunity to say, "READ before doing"
It's way too easy to look at a picture and glance at the instructions and THINK you know what to do next. This was a mistake that won't hurt anything, but the next mistake could mean ripping everything apart and re-doing it
It's way too easy to look at a picture and glance at the instructions and THINK you know what to do next. This was a mistake that won't hurt anything, but the next mistake could mean ripping everything apart and re-doing it
#9

My Feedback: (1)
You can see what wing stall is all about if you go over to Van's Aircraft web and click on the RV-12 stall/spin testing video's half way down the page. They have the wing and fuselage tuffed so that you can see how a stall develops. Notice the angle of the horizon in the background as the pilot slows down the aircraft for an unaccelerated stall.
http://www.vansaircraft.com/
http://www.vansaircraft.com/
#11
ORIGINAL: HighPlains
You can see what wing stall is all about if you go over to Van's Aircraft web and click on the RV-12 stall/spin testing video's half way down the page. They have the wing and fuselage tuffed so that you can see how a stall develops. Notice the angle of the horizon in the background as the pilot slows down the aircraft for an unaccelerated stall.
http://www.vansaircraft.com/
You can see what wing stall is all about if you go over to Van's Aircraft web and click on the RV-12 stall/spin testing video's half way down the page. They have the wing and fuselage tuffed so that you can see how a stall develops. Notice the angle of the horizon in the background as the pilot slows down the aircraft for an unaccelerated stall.
http://www.vansaircraft.com/




