upgrading RX/TX batteries
#3
Senior Member
For TX batteries, NiMH can often give you appreciably more capacity in the basically fixed volume of the battery box. And those batteries are ok for the basically constant demands a TX makes.
I've seen two very respected battery experts state unequivocally that Sanyo makes the best NiCd's. And that it's worth using them exclusively. Don't know if it's still good advice, but I've seen nothing to disprove it.
I've seen two very respected battery experts state unequivocally that Sanyo makes the best NiCd's. And that it's worth using them exclusively. Don't know if it's still good advice, but I've seen nothing to disprove it.
#4
Thread Starter
Senior Member
My Feedback: (13)
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,322
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nutley,
NJ
So are nicds recommended over nimh for rx power? Right now I am running the stock 4.8V 600Mah nicd and am looking for longer duration.
Can the Futaba receiver battery cycler be used on the tx battery as well?
Can the Futaba receiver battery cycler be used on the tx battery as well?
#5
Thread Starter
Senior Member
My Feedback: (13)
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,322
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nutley,
NJ
to ANSWER MY OWN QUESTION...tHE FUTABA CYCLER DOES NOT WORK WITH tx BATTERIES.
WHAT ARE YOU GUYS USING/DOING TO CYCLE YOUR TX/RX BATTERIES?
WHAT ARE YOU GUYS USING/DOING TO CYCLE YOUR TX/RX BATTERIES?
#6

My Feedback: (12)
ORIGINAL: ro347
So are nicds recommended over nimh for rx power? Right now I am running the stock 4.8V 600Mah nicd and am looking for longer duration.
So are nicds recommended over nimh for rx power? Right now I am running the stock 4.8V 600Mah nicd and am looking for longer duration.
#7

My Feedback: (12)
ORIGINAL: ro347
WHAT ARE YOU GUYS USING/DOING TO CYCLE YOUR TX/RX BATTERIES?
WHAT ARE YOU GUYS USING/DOING TO CYCLE YOUR TX/RX BATTERIES?
#8

My Feedback: (2)
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 4,045
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Sailing in the Eastern Caribbean
But if you fly a lot and rely on the TX voltage readout be aware that the drop off in voltage with NiMh is MUCH steeper than Nicads.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
#9
Senior Member
www.vapextech.co.uk
a 2400mah 4.8v RX battery for £5, and a 2100 NiMh for £10
i prefer NiMh's because you can just top them up before you go flying and your pack wont suffer
a 2400mah 4.8v RX battery for £5, and a 2100 NiMh for £10
i prefer NiMh's because you can just top them up before you go flying and your pack wont suffer
#11
Thread Starter
Senior Member
My Feedback: (13)
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,322
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nutley,
NJ
ORIGINAL: j.duncker
But if you fly a lot and rely on the TX voltage readout be aware that the drop off in voltage with NiMh is MUCH steeper than Nicads.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
But if you fly a lot and rely on the TX voltage readout be aware that the drop off in voltage with NiMh is MUCH steeper than Nicads.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
#12
Here is a good source of information on NiCd and NiMH battery packs: www.rcbatteryclinic.com The author is a retired battery engineer and a moderator on RC Universe.
My opinion is stay with NiCd unless you need the extra capacity of NiMH. NiCd packs have a longer shelf life, lower self discharge rate, and in general I feel are slightly more reliable then NiMH. I fly all day with 1100 mAh Sanyo NiCd packs in both my Tx and Rx. On the other hand, if you need the extra capacity then by all means go to NiMH.
By the way, the original equipment battery packs that come from Futaba and Tower Hobbies seem to be of excellent quality. Another good source is www.radicalrc.com
My opinion is stay with NiCd unless you need the extra capacity of NiMH. NiCd packs have a longer shelf life, lower self discharge rate, and in general I feel are slightly more reliable then NiMH. I fly all day with 1100 mAh Sanyo NiCd packs in both my Tx and Rx. On the other hand, if you need the extra capacity then by all means go to NiMH.
By the way, the original equipment battery packs that come from Futaba and Tower Hobbies seem to be of excellent quality. Another good source is www.radicalrc.com
#13

Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 4,865
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Jacksonville, FL
ro347 the charge jack on Futaba transmitters are diode protected if you want to call it protected. this will not allow the battery to be discharged through the charge jack. to deep cycle a tx battery leave the radio on and monitor the voltage. or remove the battery and discharge like a rx battery
deep cycle a Nicad to prevent memory, doesn't mean if you don't deep cycle you will develope a memory. all batteries are different and it depends on their use
deep cycle a Nicad to prevent memory, doesn't mean if you don't deep cycle you will develope a memory. all batteries are different and it depends on their use
#14
ORIGINAL: j.duncker
But if you fly a lot and rely on the TX voltage readout be aware that the drop off in voltage with NiMh is MUCH steeper than Nicads.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
But if you fly a lot and rely on the TX voltage readout be aware that the drop off in voltage with NiMh is MUCH steeper than Nicads.
I have less than 90 seconds between my low batt. alarm going off and TX shutdown on a Futaba FF9 with 1800 mah NiMh pack.
I have a 2100 mah NiMh in my Futaba and the lowest I have ever seen it was 9.9v after a long weekend, usually it is above 10v for quite a few flights.
#15
Thread Starter
Senior Member
My Feedback: (13)
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,322
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nutley,
NJ
ORIGINAL: jetmech05
ro347 the charge jack on Futaba transmitters are diode protected if you want to call it protected. this will not allow the battery to be discharged through the charge jack. to deep cycle a tx battery leave the radio on and monitor the voltage. or remove the battery and discharge like a rx battery
deep cycle a Nicad to prevent memory, doesn't mean if you don't deep cycle you will develope a memory. all batteries are different and it depends on their use
ro347 the charge jack on Futaba transmitters are diode protected if you want to call it protected. this will not allow the battery to be discharged through the charge jack. to deep cycle a tx battery leave the radio on and monitor the voltage. or remove the battery and discharge like a rx battery
deep cycle a Nicad to prevent memory, doesn't mean if you don't deep cycle you will develope a memory. all batteries are different and it depends on their use
#16
Senior Member
The only reason to cycle either NiMh or NiCad is to check to see if they are still up to capacity, maybe once or twice a year. The way the batteries are used in transmitters and receivers never creates the so called memory syndrome which is pretty much a myth anyway. If you are using the slow chargers that usually come with the transmitter/receiver package, just charge over night before the fly day and enjoy. No need to discharge first either even if you never flew since you last charged them. As to discharging by turning on the transmitter and letting it run, there are two cautions. Do not run for an extended time with the antenna collapsed as it may damage the output stage as the energy normally radiated as RF is now dissipated as heat in the output stage. If you run with the antenna up, make sure there is no one else within two miles trying to use that frequency while you polluting the airwaves with needless RF.
#17

My Feedback: (2)
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 4,045
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
From: Sailing in the Eastern Caribbean
I fly a lot. Cries of PEG_HOG and how big is the tank on that thing have been heard.
But it is when I am sloping that I have to watch my TX batt. I think the LCD displays on modern computer radios might be part of the problem.
But it is when I am sloping that I have to watch my TX batt. I think the LCD displays on modern computer radios might be part of the problem.



