Not sure where to go
#1
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Beaverton,
OR
I`ve been flying for a couple months now, my main outdoor plane is my trusty FlyZone Sky Fly and I`ve soloed on that and my parkzone ember, and I can fly both pretty well I have experiance with 4 channel planes though most of it is in simulators, however I feel quite confident with my skills and I`m not sure where to go from here, the Sky Fly is a beginner plane and the Ember is an intermediate but they`re both three channel, I`m not sure whether I should go to a low wing (not a aerobat or stunt plane) or a high wing trainer, I want to move up and I know that I can, I`m just not sure how fast to, basically, I want to know if I can save a few bucks and go directly to a low wing.
#2
Personally, I'd go for a typical high wing trainer. While you do have some experience with RC flying, which will be extremely helpful, the planes you mentioned are not going to be the same as what you will be stepping up to.
On option might be to get a more "advanced" trainer. Something like the Hobbico Avistar or World Models Skyraider Mach-1 both have semi-symetrical airfoil and shallow dihedral. This makes them better at aerobatic maneuvers but they are still relatively gentle and forgiving.
I would also ask around at your local club and see what is popular there and what they recommend.
The bottom line is that there is nothing wrong with a high wing trainer. You'll likely even see a lot of experienced pilots at your club playing around with one from time to time.
On option might be to get a more "advanced" trainer. Something like the Hobbico Avistar or World Models Skyraider Mach-1 both have semi-symetrical airfoil and shallow dihedral. This makes them better at aerobatic maneuvers but they are still relatively gentle and forgiving.
I would also ask around at your local club and see what is popular there and what they recommend.
The bottom line is that there is nothing wrong with a high wing trainer. You'll likely even see a lot of experienced pilots at your club playing around with one from time to time.
#3
I would go with a high wing trainer but one with a semi-symetrical wing like the Avistar.
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...I=LXMU53**&P=0
It is still a trainer and very forgiving yet very capable of flying most aerobatics.
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...I=LXMU53**&P=0
It is still a trainer and very forgiving yet very capable of flying most aerobatics.
#4
If you manage to swing by a local club on training night, you may be able to give a plane a flight and see how much you really have a handle on it using a club trainer. One or two flights, and you will have a much better idea. Also, someone there may have something used you could get interested in, you could save some real cash.
#6
Senior Member
ORIGINAL: drZoidBeRg365
I want to move up and I know that I can, I`m just not sure how fast to, basically, I want to know if I can save a few bucks and go directly to a low wing.
I want to move up and I know that I can, I`m just not sure how fast to, basically, I want to know if I can save a few bucks and go directly to a low wing.
Can you go directly to a low wing? You betcha. If you go to the right one, you'll be an odds on favorite to succeed.
The Tigers are excellent models. They also happen to be very, very good trainers. They just happen be low wing. Super Sportsters are very good. The new GP Cherokee is a very good low wing and looks less like just a model and more like a fullscale. Four Stars are good, but their wing construction is a bit damage prone (not full LE support). The Calmato Sport is as good as any of the above.
hhhmmmmmmmmmmmmmm....
#7
ORIGINAL: drZoidBeRg365
Do you by chance have any knowledge of how the Hobbico Electristar handles?
Do you by chance have any knowledge of how the Hobbico Electristar handles?
It will be slow on rolls and not want to fly inverted without some work but it will be good practice for a more aerobatic plane.
#8
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Beaverton,
OR
This may start a controversy like on the "The P-51 PTS is NOT a good trainer" thread but would a slightly modified PTS with the reccomended 10 X 7 prop work, theres one down at my LHS on discount for $300
#9
Senior Member
ORIGINAL: drZoidBeRg365
This may start a controversy like on the "The P-51 PTS is NOT a good trainer" thread but would a slightly modified PTS with the reccomended 10 X 7 prop work, theres one down at my LHS on discount for $300
This may start a controversy like on the "The P-51 PTS is NOT a good trainer" thread but would a slightly modified PTS with the reccomended 10 X 7 prop work, theres one down at my LHS on discount for $300
The P51 PTS would not be as good as most straight wing low wingers. It has a tapered wing and they naturally stall from the tips. Straight wings naturally stall from the root. It's why trainers (that deserve the name) do not have tapered wings. That P51 is a decent P51 model with all the "training aides" removed, but it's not as good a flyer as any of the straight wings mentioned so far. Why? Because when a tapered wing stalls (as sometimes happens to beginners learning to land) the plane rolls when it stalls and the loss in altitude is often appreciably quicker than when a straight wing stalls. Both sides of the tapered wing are equally apt to stall, but one will beat the other in almost every case. And when that happens the model also yaws. Forces at the tips (and loss of force at the tips) have more leverage than forces at the center of the wing. So you get more effect, more changes of direction, and it's quicker with a tapered wing. And that P51 has a tapered wing.
#10
ORIGINAL: drZoidBeRg365
This may start a controversy like on the "The P-51 PTS is NOT a good trainer" thread but would a slightly modified PTS with the reccomended 10 X 7 prop work, theres one down at my LHS on discount for $300
This may start a controversy like on the "The P-51 PTS is NOT a good trainer" thread but would a slightly modified PTS with the reccomended 10 X 7 prop work, theres one down at my LHS on discount for $300
You are already flying a couple of 3 channel electrics so in your situation I say:
IF you will be working with an instructor you may do well with the PTS.
IF you are just going to assemble it and go out and fly with no help get a traditional high wing trainer.




