2 Stroke vs. 4 Stroke
#26
Get the YS dialed in and hammer the throttle one time and you'll quickly forget about fuel consumption and other stuff. The OS 1.20 is good but the YS is in another category alltogether.
#27
Member
My Feedback: (8)
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Fallon,
NV
<span style="font-family: Tahoma"><span style="font-size: medium"><span style="color: #000080">A little history of the YS 4s engines.
Did you know that Surer Tigre developed the engine a very long time ago!
Their concept of crankcase supercharging was the first in model avaition!
The modeling comunity thought the engine wasn't worth the effort to try it!
ST's boss sold the tooling and rights toa japaneese firm.
YS spent much time and money pushing the 4s concept.
Pattern flyers were the first to use it fully, when cu in limitations were imposed.
I'm afraid that the time frame escapes me but, it happened over 25 years ago. I can stand to be corrected!
OS tried to SC one of their 1.20s. Used a Roots type blower, engine driven, to match YS. Never did!
But OS 120 supercharged engines ARE a thing of beauty. They never achieved the HP that a YS did, and were more prone to wear.
I use YS engines and, yes, they have a sound that can't be beat and they deliver the torque!
I also like the sound of big hairy radial engines...ie PW4360 ! PW2800 ! CW3350 and the list goes on.....
POP POP POP goes the 2 stroke..... GRRRRR goes my YS !!

I love a good discussion!
M Zorger
AMA129570
</span></span></span>
Did you know that Surer Tigre developed the engine a very long time ago!
Their concept of crankcase supercharging was the first in model avaition!
The modeling comunity thought the engine wasn't worth the effort to try it!
ST's boss sold the tooling and rights toa japaneese firm.
YS spent much time and money pushing the 4s concept.
Pattern flyers were the first to use it fully, when cu in limitations were imposed.
I'm afraid that the time frame escapes me but, it happened over 25 years ago. I can stand to be corrected!
OS tried to SC one of their 1.20s. Used a Roots type blower, engine driven, to match YS. Never did!
But OS 120 supercharged engines ARE a thing of beauty. They never achieved the HP that a YS did, and were more prone to wear.
I use YS engines and, yes, they have a sound that can't be beat and they deliver the torque!
I also like the sound of big hairy radial engines...ie PW4360 ! PW2800 ! CW3350 and the list goes on.....

POP POP POP goes the 2 stroke..... GRRRRR goes my YS !!

I love a good discussion!
M Zorger
AMA129570
</span></span></span>
#28

My Feedback: (-1)
Nope, didn't know that but my advanced flight instructor was one of the first guys in this country to get the YS for pattern flying. He was working at a big hobby shop at the time. He got me into the YS by allowing me to fly his CG Extra with the YS 1.20NC then my CG Extra with the OS 1.20, my plane was a bit lighter but it was apples and oranges. With the price jump by Saito and OS I can't understand anyone buying them when they can get a YS.
Does it sound like I'm sold on them?? Plus I can buy any and all parts for a YS without having to send them in for service. Another big plus.
Does it sound like I'm sold on them?? Plus I can buy any and all parts for a YS without having to send them in for service. Another big plus.
#29

My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 939
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Rochester,
NY
Here's a little video I put together of a few planes, the first being a YS FZ110-S in a QuiQue 72"Yak,
that demonstrates the sweet sound and power of this engine. Click HD on lower right after clicking below link.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itCeAX0HRlU
that demonstrates the sweet sound and power of this engine. Click HD on lower right after clicking below link.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itCeAX0HRlU
#31

My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 939
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Rochester,
NY
Thanks!The waiver is pending
By the way, looking at your hangar - very impressive!You seem to be mainly an OS guy though, didn't see any YS engines.
By the way, looking at your hangar - very impressive!You seem to be mainly an OS guy though, didn't see any YS engines.
ORIGINAL: ChuckW
Good video. What kind of AMA waver do you need for that space shuttle in the beginning?
Good video. What kind of AMA waver do you need for that space shuttle in the beginning?

#33
Senior Member
There's no dispute that YS 4-strokes produce best-in-class power for any given engine size, but to get that power you have to use high nitro fuel (20% ormore)andthe costcan start to add up.
I'm kinda like Gray Beard. I like the 2-strokes that can turn large props. My personal preference is for Webra's. Nitro in Europe is expensive so engines made there typically peform really well on very little nitro.
I have a Webra .91 2-strokethat runs extremely welland effortlessly turns a 15x8 prop in the mid 9's. Remember, this is on FAI fuel or 5% nitro so my fuel costs are considerably cheaper. The OS equivelent can't even reach those rpms on 15% fuel.
Can any tell me what a YS 1.10 turns15x8, 16x6 and16x6 props at?
</p>
#35

My Feedback: (-1)
ORIGINAL: CustomPC
There's no dispute that YS 4-strokes produce best-in-class power for any given engine size, but to get that power you have to use high nitro fuel (20% ormore)andthe costcan start to add up.
I'm kinda like Gray Beard. I like the 2-strokes that can turn large props. My personal preference is for Webra's. Nitro in Europe is expensive so engines made there typically peform really well on very little nitro.
I have a Webra .91 2-strokethat runs extremely welland effortlessly turns a 15x8 prop in the mid 9's. Remember, this is on FAI fuel or 5% nitro so my fuel costs are considerably cheaper. The OS equivelent can't even reach those rpms on 15% fuel.
Can any tell me what a YS 1.10 turns15x8, 16x6 and16x6 props at?
They don't require the nitro, it just makes it easier for people to set the low end, Ihave run them on 5% and other then the idle they run just fine. Only glow fuel Ibuy is 15% and I'm a YS guy.
Irun the 16X6 and 16X4 APCs on my 1.10s and Iget about the same readings as Joe, maybe a little less?? Been a couple of months sense I put a tach on one, a lot depends on how you tune them, Imay be a tad fatter then Joe, OK, Iknow I'm fatter then Joe but we are talking engines!
Iwas the pit man for a racer that was running the Webras, another good engine. Idon't know how low on nitro Ican go with the SKs but Ihave a friend running a big Moki so I may borrow some of his FAI and see how they {it} do?? Right now I'm only running the one SK .91 two strokes, Iam running a couple of gassers and the rest are four strokes, one OS. I have no problems with the other four strokes, I just like the YS best!!</p>
There's no dispute that YS 4-strokes produce best-in-class power for any given engine size, but to get that power you have to use high nitro fuel (20% ormore)andthe costcan start to add up.
I'm kinda like Gray Beard. I like the 2-strokes that can turn large props. My personal preference is for Webra's. Nitro in Europe is expensive so engines made there typically peform really well on very little nitro.
I have a Webra .91 2-strokethat runs extremely welland effortlessly turns a 15x8 prop in the mid 9's. Remember, this is on FAI fuel or 5% nitro so my fuel costs are considerably cheaper. The OS equivelent can't even reach those rpms on 15% fuel.
Can any tell me what a YS 1.10 turns15x8, 16x6 and16x6 props at?
They don't require the nitro, it just makes it easier for people to set the low end, Ihave run them on 5% and other then the idle they run just fine. Only glow fuel Ibuy is 15% and I'm a YS guy.
Irun the 16X6 and 16X4 APCs on my 1.10s and Iget about the same readings as Joe, maybe a little less?? Been a couple of months sense I put a tach on one, a lot depends on how you tune them, Imay be a tad fatter then Joe, OK, Iknow I'm fatter then Joe but we are talking engines!
Iwas the pit man for a racer that was running the Webras, another good engine. Idon't know how low on nitro Ican go with the SKs but Ihave a friend running a big Moki so I may borrow some of his FAI and see how they {it} do?? Right now I'm only running the one SK .91 two strokes, Iam running a couple of gassers and the rest are four strokes, one OS. I have no problems with the other four strokes, I just like the YS best!!</p>
#36
Junior Member
Joined: Dec 2019
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I’m late to this thread but I have gone through it and still confused.
I'm a beginner and haven’t done my A cert yet but it was the sound of combustion aeroplane that triggered that bug in me.
If I ask something stupid, please ignore it as I’m still a beginner and I’m aware I’m asking a lot of questions.
I want to know the comparison between 2 stroke nitro, 4 stroke nitro, 2 stroke gasser and 4 stroke gasser.
The information that I would like is
And if someone can also do a comparison on these lines between
I'm a beginner and haven’t done my A cert yet but it was the sound of combustion aeroplane that triggered that bug in me.
If I ask something stupid, please ignore it as I’m still a beginner and I’m aware I’m asking a lot of questions.
I want to know the comparison between 2 stroke nitro, 4 stroke nitro, 2 stroke gasser and 4 stroke gasser.
The information that I would like is
- what type of fuel or fuel mix
- the ‘cool or the sound’ factor (after all this is the original cause of all ills
) - mess that it creates
- Maintainence
- original purchase cost is less of an issue but maintenance effort and cost is
- and which brand is better
And if someone can also do a comparison on these lines between
- 2 stroke nitro with 4 stroke nitro
- 2 stroke nitro And 2 stroke gasser
- 2 stroke nitro and 4 stroke gasser
- 4 stroke nitro and 2 stroke gasser
- 4 stroke nitro and 4 stroke gasser
- 2 stroke gasser and 4 stroke gasser (I want this the most)
#37

My Feedback: (19)
For the T-Two Stroke fanatics: The F-F-F-Four Cycle Page
For the F-F-F-Four Stroke fanatics: The T-Two Cycle Page
For the F-F-F-Four Stroke fanatics: The T-Two Cycle Page
#38

My Feedback: (4)
Sounds like an inept tuner to me if one can't tune a 2 stroke or a 4 stroke to idle, reading the foolishness and false information in those links. I'd avoid any posts from incompetent users that blame the engine. They likely also destroy their batteries as well unable to handle the electric component of the hobby also. The glow engine has been around 80 years, give or take? It wouldn't have passed down generations if everyone had the same conclusions of those not capable of learning but create misleading websites linked above.
If you decide to get into gas or glow, I watch others who pay a premium for gas and do just fine, but I've yet to see one perform as well as glow or be as lightweight. For the amount of flying you do a month, would determine if the fuel savings is right for you to make gas truly worthwhile an investment, and go through the learning curve on brands, tuning, etc. which you would do anyway with glow to some degree. But, I suggest you shop from FB, CL, local club, or RCG, find a local sale with the engine, servos, and plane ready to go as a used package that someone no longer wants, than piece meal each or buy new. Doing that, you'll always find glow and very few gas powered plane packages, but you'll get in the air on a budget, especially if this is just an experiment that you may not continue, at least you got in the air for a lot less money and can always get out of it for what you paid.
- what type of fuel or fuel mix
- the cool or the sound factor (after all this is the original cause of all ills
)
- mess that it creates
- Maintenance
- original purchase cost is less of an issue but maintenance effort and cost is
- and which brand is better
If you decide to get into gas or glow, I watch others who pay a premium for gas and do just fine, but I've yet to see one perform as well as glow or be as lightweight. For the amount of flying you do a month, would determine if the fuel savings is right for you to make gas truly worthwhile an investment, and go through the learning curve on brands, tuning, etc. which you would do anyway with glow to some degree. But, I suggest you shop from FB, CL, local club, or RCG, find a local sale with the engine, servos, and plane ready to go as a used package that someone no longer wants, than piece meal each or buy new. Doing that, you'll always find glow and very few gas powered plane packages, but you'll get in the air on a budget, especially if this is just an experiment that you may not continue, at least you got in the air for a lot less money and can always get out of it for what you paid.



