![]() |
Brown out refers to flight power voltage drop. There can be several causes with the most often cause to be too great of load.
Edit: my answer was likely incomplete.. as it colloquially means that the reception ability of the receiver is degraded due to the lower power of the flight system due to higher energy demands. |
Originally Posted by AA5BY
(Post 12354229)
Brown out refers to flight power voltage drop. There can be several causes with the most often cause to be too great of load.
Edit: my answer was likely incomplete.. as it colloquially means that the reception ability of the receiver is degraded due to the lower power of the flight system due to higher energy demands. |
Digital servos require greater energy than standards for example so any system with a full house (four or more) digital servos should be a 6v system rather than 4.8 so as to avoid brown out. To make this easy... any plane larger or more complicated than a sport .60 size should probably use a 6v system.
|
Originally Posted by AA5BY
(Post 12354240)
Digital servos require greater energy than standards for example so any system with a full house (four or more) digital servos should be a 6v system rather than 4.8 so as to avoid brown out. To make this easy... any plane larger or more complicated than a sport .60 size should probably use a 6v system.
|
Originally Posted by boner321
(Post 12354243)
I just started flying recently, so IDK what any of that means. LOL
|
Originally Posted by boner321
(Post 12354227)
Thank you. Also, what's a brown out?
|
Originally Posted by boner321
(Post 12354243)
I just started flying recently, so IDK what any of that means. LOL
1) Brown out-pretty much covered but it's not enough battery for the load placed on it causing the servos to react slowly to not at all 2) Full house aircraft-one that has servos operating all the basic functions; ailerons, rudder, elevator and throttle. 3) Servo types-Servos have changed a lot over the years:
5) Transmitter Functions-These need to be gone over with an instructor since not everything your transmitter can do is needed by a trainer |
Always use 6v or better packs in the plane. If going higher than 6v make sure the rx and servos are rated for the higher voltage.
I strongly recommend you use professionally built packs with soldered or welded connections. Loose cells in holders have caused many a crash. |
Originally Posted by j.duncker
(Post 12354883)
Always use 6v or better packs in the plane. If going higher than 6v make sure the rx and servos are rated for the higher voltage.
I strongly recommend you use professionally built packs with soldered or welded connections. Loose cells in holders have caused many a crash. |
If a servo makes enough torque at 4.8v to operate the control surface it is attached to, then there isn't a problem using 4.8v. But it has become standard practice with RC planes to use 6v for two reasons. First, it lets us use a little bit lower end servo and still get the torque we need. Second, it prevents the aforementioned brownouts.
|
Originally Posted by jester_s1
(Post 12355041)
If a servo makes enough torque at 4.8v to operate the control surface it is attached to, then there isn't a problem using 4.8v. But it has become standard practice with RC planes to use 6v for two reasons. First, it lets us use a little bit lower end servo and still get the torque we need. Second, it prevents the aforementioned brownouts.
94102 Precision Heavy Duty Bushed Standard 50oz-in at 4.8 volts, .22 second transit time for 60 degrees If that's what was listed when the kit was first kitted, why do I need to use a 6 volt pack now? It wasn't needed back then so why the change? Is it because it's needed or just because it's there to satisfy those that think they need, to quote Tim Allen, "MORE POWER"? |
You don't need to use 6v but it may be convenient to do so. I've fifteen plus planes in the hanger, all of them use LiFe battery technology because doing so simplifies things.
That said, I do have one old Cub flight system and a couple of ignitions with 4.8v restrictions. I've chosen to voltage drop for those requirements with diodes. Each RC pilot has choices of what works best for them. There are no requirements that one must do things like others. If a method works for you... your good. |
Hi Boner 321, I got back into rc after a 10 plus year lapse and went with 4.8 volt nicads for my recievers(it is what I know). The plus to this is that the charger that comes with your radio will charge them(400 to 700 MAH range). the disadvantage is first, nicads will form a memory and need to be run down(not too much though) to around 1.1 volt per cell before charging. Another disadvantage is at 400 to 700 MAH I am limited to around 3 flights. I will switch all my stuff over to LIFE once it is time to change them out(five years?) I am not sure even if life is the same voltage per cell as nicad, but for me 4.8 volts is all I need as I fly 40 size birds. I have built battery cyclers for all my aircraft so I can simply plug each of my 5 aircraft into a cycler and it will automatically discharge and recharge by receiver battery whith the battery still in the aircraft.
|
For anyone worried about ' burning out a servo ' on 6v instead of 4.8 v I have run a large variety of servos on 6v without any issues at all. Everything from sub miniature 2.4g indoor stuff to the brick size stuff in 150 cc 3 D monsters. You get a little more torque and a little more speed both of which are good. No body in the clubs I flew with ever reported a burnt out servo.
My main concern with advising beginners to avoid running on 4.8v is that some 2.4 gh receivers can temporarily fail and lock up when the voltage drops below a critical threshold even momentarily. This is called a brown out. Lots more here on this topic http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/begi...-brownout.html Running 6 v is a low cost insurance policy. |
Originally Posted by Hydro Junkie
(Post 12354964)
Why? I run digital servos in my 1/8 scale hydroplane that are rated at 4.8 volts for the throttle while the rudder servo is dual rated at 4.8 and 6 volts. The load on the rudder servo is several times higher than anything you will ever see on airplanes and it works fine at racing speeds on 4.8 volts. I've run a full weekend, totaling eight five to six minute heats on one NR4J 600mah 4.8 volt pack without recharging the pack. Come to think about it, I charged that pack with a "wall wart" charger a few days prior to that weekend, put it in the boat and never pulled the radio box tape off until I'd been home for three days
|
Originally Posted by Desertlakesflying
(Post 12355163)
You are running two servos that are not constantly in motion....instead of 4 or more that are constantly in motion...
The standard race course shall: be oval in shape have two parallel straightaways be a minimum of 60 feet from the closest shore have dimensions that must be: turns 60’ to 120’ in diameter and straightaways 275’ to 400’ in length Taking all of that into consideration, a boat doing 50 MPH will go the length of the straight in less than 3.5 seconds and complete the turn at one end in around 1 second if the boat is running right on the buoy line.. Unlike an airplane, my boat's rudder is constantly having to hold pressure on its left side as the prop is trying to push the boat's transom to the left. Also, the rudder, prop, and turn fin are going through a substance that 784 times more dense than the air meaning that the servo has to deal with 784 times the pressure on every square inch of the rudder that is in the water as compared to a control surfaces on an aircraft This means that a boat rudder servo alone will used much more power than the combined total used by the servos of an airplane. By the way, my boat weighs in at 14lbs and runs a .67 that can turn up to 28,000 RPM, more than twice the speed of a similar sized aircraft engine https://static.wixstatic.com/media/1...d0a973d93.webp |
True, the torque requirements for servo speed haven't changed. For trainers and basic sport planes, no one "needs" 6v servo performance.
However... In the days when 4 cell NiCd packs became standard, we had analog servos and 72mhz radios. Analog servos weren't power hungry, and 72mhz radios were very tolerant of low voltage situations. Today, nearly everyone flies 2.4ghz, quite a few the Spektrum brand. Spektrum equipped planes will often crash just from a split second drop below 3.5v. Analog servos probably won't cause that with a good 4.8v pack, but if the pack is marginal and the pilot is really working the sticks, it can definitely happen. Digital servos will routinely cause a 1v and more voltage drop when they start demanding power, so it becomes good practice to use 6v batteries and be done with it. Very few currently manufactured servos are 4.8v only, so there isn't much reason not to go ahead and use 6v. |
For someone starting out, like myself, sounds like 6 vt is the way to go regardless of what I fly, just to avoid the possible brown out.
|
Originally Posted by rmatt
(Post 12355354)
For someone starting out, like myself, sounds like 6 vt is the way to go regardless of what I fly, just to avoid the possible brown out.
For many years now I advise all my students or any who would listen To Never use a 4.8 volt Nimh/Nicd with any brand 2.4 system. In those early years Spectrum took the biggest hit with these brown outs happening almost everywhere. Problem was the manufacturers reluctance to tell folks that their old 4.8's was just not suited to this new technology. I first started using 2.4 with XPS which beat Spectrum with full range 2.4 by just a few weeks then later three generations of Hitec 2.4 and currently for my most expensive stuff Futaba (FASST) But guess what I have never experienced a brownout with any of it. John:cool: |
To be fair, Spektrum really is the only manufacturer that has an issue with radio voltage, at least as far as I know. 3.5v is the cutoff for them. At that point, the receiver shuts off and will reboot itself when the voltage rises above 3.5v. It takes about a second for that to happen, so it may cause a crash, or you may not even know it has happened at all. Other manufacturers saw the early problems Spektrum had back when the reset time was 3 seconds and designed receivers that can work with lower voltage. Realistically, Futaba, Hitec, and JR receivers shouldn't experience brownouts with any 4.8v pack that is appropriately sized for the plane it is in. That said, you pay a 1/2 ounce weight penalty for that extra cell and maybe $5, so there isn't much reason not to have it.
|
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:31 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.