RCU Forums

RCU Forums (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/)
-   Beginners (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/beginners-85/)
-   -   How do they do that???? (https://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/beginners-85/6443582-how-do-they-do.html)

goirish 10-03-2007 06:15 AM

How do they do that????
 
Looking at the cover of Model Aviation October 2007 and wonder how do they get covering like that. I am bascially a scratch builder and I can cover pretty good, but I can't compete with that :(. I would really like to see that done [8D].

Nathan King 10-03-2007 06:54 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
In one word... Practice.

Those older guys have been covering since they were teenagers. You'll get there in no time.

By the way, you are looking at the COVER of MA. That's where the best of the best go. Don't try to compare yourself to that yet.

goirish 10-03-2007 06:59 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
Sure would like to see that done.

seemefly_1 10-03-2007 03:43 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
I'm still wondering how big that plane is[>:]
or how those tabs work

da Rock 10-03-2007 04:54 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: seemefly_1

I'm still wondering how big that plane is[>:]
or how those tabs work
It's a 40%.

Those are booster tabs and actually drive the ailerons or help drive them depending. It's an excellent way to only use a couple of aileron servos instead of a line of them along each wing. Driving the tab in the opposite direction you want the aileron to go moves the aileron in the direction you want it to do. Aero does the work for you. One servo to drive the tab. Amazing why it's not done by everyone. The idea that it isn't as accurate seems to be a joke looking at that airplane do what it can do, which is what every other one of 'em can do. He just does it with less equipment, weight, and expense. Go figure.

da Rock 10-03-2007 05:05 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: goirish

Looking at the cover of Model Aviation October 2007 and wonder how do they get covering like that. I am bascially a scratch builder and I can cover pretty good, but I can't compete with that :(. I would really like to see that done [8D].

Actually you could do that just like they do. Go to a sign shop that does vinyl, which most of them do nowadays. And have 'em run you off some templates if they don't have machines that do Monokote. Give them the measurements and a plan. They do the hard part.

Then you clean off the dining room floor and take 30 or 40 rolls of Monokote and have at it.

Iron on ain't so hard. Have you ever seen one of the Control Line Precision Aerobatics models that have even more intricate designs? They're painted. And have to not only be gorgeous but light. And light really matters. Really. And the Goodyear Pylon racers of some years back looked as good. Actually often looked better on average because they actually didn't have the weight problem as bad.

But that big sucker does look good doesn't it. Iron on or not.

overbored77 10-03-2007 05:13 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 

ORIGINAL: seemefly_1

I'm still wondering how big that plane is[>:]
or how those tabs work
That plane is most likely a a 40-45%, wingspan of 120" plus. Also most of those sized planes carry
a 200cc engine. In other words it's HUGE.

Stickbuilder 10-03-2007 05:20 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: da Rock



ORIGINAL: seemefly_1

I'm still wondering how big that plane is[>:]
or how those tabs work
It's a 40%.

Those are booster tabs and actually drive the ailerons or help drive them depending. It's an excellent way to only use a couple of aileron servos instead of a line of them along each wing. Driving the tab in the opposite direction you want the aileron to go moves the aileron in the direction you want it to do. Aero does the work for you. One servo to drive the tab. Amazing why it's not done by everyone. The idea that it isn't as accurate seems to be a joke looking at that airplane do what it can do, which is what every other one of 'em can do. He just does it with less equipment, weight, and expense. Go figure.
You are precisely correct, and the larger the control surface, the more the boost tabs help. I use them on lots of my scale planes (disguised as trim tabs) since I can use a smaller servo to accomplish the same thing.

Bill, AMa 4720
WACO Brotherhood #1

Stickbuilder 10-03-2007 05:23 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 

ORIGINAL: seemefly_1

I'm still wondering how big that plane is[>:]
or how those tabs work
Seemfly, the way the tabs work, is they are hinged, much the same that you would hinge a full control surface. You utilize a control horn on the tab, and affix one end of the pushrod to the control horn. The other end of the pushrod is fastened to the trailing edge of the wing/H-stab/Vstab. When the control surface is moved, it causes the boost tab to move in the opposite direction, driving the control surface harder.

Bill, AMA 4720
WACO Brotherhood #1

MinnFlyer 10-03-2007 05:32 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
There's a difference between "Hard" and "Complicated"

That covering job wouldn't be "harder" than any other - it would just TAKE a long time.

Personally, I like to find that happy-medium between "easy" and "good-looking"

seemefly_1 10-03-2007 05:39 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
thank you I understand now

ROBCAR 10-03-2007 06:14 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
I would say that covering job is actually a graphics kit custom made for that plane. The plane probably started out blue and white and then decals were applied. Just my .02

goirish 10-03-2007 06:19 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
I think you are right ROBCAR

MinnFlyer 10-03-2007 07:58 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
You can go to a local sign company that cuts vinyl graphics and give them a sheet of covering (along with the design you want) and they will cut it for you.

Charlie P. 10-03-2007 09:59 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
Are you sure it's not glassed, masked and painted?

kerrydel 10-03-2007 11:03 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
1 Attachment(s)
Here is a D&L Designs 80" Edge that I built from a short kit. I found the Red Bull logo online (I asked Red Bull, but they said they couldn't give it to me). My wife has a computerized paper cutter. I used its software to trace the outline of the figure and letters. I cut out cardstock templates that I traced on to Monokote. I resized the bull and lettering for the different spots (easy to do in the computer). I used the TLAR method to size them based on photos from airliners.net.

I think it came out pretty good.

Kerry

da Rock 10-04-2007 04:59 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: ROBCAR

I would say that covering job is actually a graphics kit custom made for that plane. The plane probably started out blue and white and then decals were applied. Just my .02

You mean, like the guy went to a graphics place and got them to make the design up for him? Like to a sign shop?

da Rock 10-04-2007 05:07 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: Charlie P.

Are you sure it's not glassed, masked and painted?

I got $20 says it's not painted. Almost always, when someone nowadays has the skill to paint, they use a gun or airbrush, and will almost surely do some fade somewhere. And does anybody glass something that large nowadays? For that matter, any size?

As for how large the airplane is? If you got the magazine cover, open it and read the writeup. The magazine says it's a 40%.

Hey, about the graphics on the sucker.......... check this out http://www.riversiderc.com/page5/page40/page40.html Graphics look familiar? What does that tell ya'.

goirish 10-04-2007 05:22 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
DaRock---How do you find all that stuff? I'm amazed.

Cyclic Hardover 10-04-2007 08:08 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
1 Attachment(s)


ORIGINAL: goirish

Looking at the cover of Model Aviation October 2007 and wonder how do they get covering like that. I am bascially a scratch builder and I can cover pretty good, but I can't compete with that :(. I would really like to see that done [8D].


Same way you get photos uploaded, Practice!:D Just pulling your chain!

da Rock 10-04-2007 09:23 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: goirish

DaRock---How do you find all that stuff? I'm amazed.
I'm retired and love this stuff. Read a lot and have the magazine. Magazines always have a paragraph that describes the cover and that led to the article that gave more about the airplane. And best of all, I know Bill Hamby.

And think this forum stuff is great fun. Which it is, ain't it...........

Kaos Rulz 10-04-2007 09:40 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
Does anyone have a picture, or a sketch, of these power tabs showing how they work?

Stickbuilder 10-04-2007 02:57 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: ED STEFAN

Does anyone have a picture, or a sketch, of these power tabs showing how they work?
Ed, see the post by me above, and look at the photo on your copy of the mag. The end of the pushrod that attaches to the trailing edge of the wing or stabilizer does not move. As the control surface begind to move, it forces the boost tab to move opposite the movement of the control surface, forcing the control surface to move easier, and faster.

Bill, AMA 4720
WACO Brotherhood #1

bruce88123 10-04-2007 03:00 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
Here ya go
http://www.geocities.com/roger_forgues/Boost-tabs.html

da Rock 10-04-2007 03:52 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
1 Attachment(s)


ORIGINAL: ED STEFAN

Does anyone have a picture, or a sketch, of these power tabs showing how they work?

Here is a side view with everything neutral.

da Rock 10-04-2007 03:58 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
1 Attachment(s)
And with the aileron deflected.

The rigid horn on the TE of the wing keeps the boost tab pushrod localized and when the aileron moves, the tab is pushed or pulled in the opposite direction.

da Rock 10-04-2007 04:01 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
OK, I see Bruces link is working now, and it's an excellent description. It appears to offer some numbers with it.

In our modeling application, the tab can reduce the force needed to drive any of our surfaces. With the big models those forces can go way beyond what our servo's can give. And we often wind up with 2 or 3 servos, each of which costs big bucks, working just one aileron. Not good economics. And beyond the money, it's a royal pain. The servos have to be sync'ed for one. Installed for another. A royal pain.

It's actually amazing that they aren't on every big bird of ours. Guess not many model designers know about them. Or maybe the servo mfg's are paying hush money. ;)

vmsguy 10-05-2007 08:36 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
I wonder if there's a practical size limit to using boost tabs.

By that I mean, when is a control surface (and by inference the plane) too small to make boost tabs not worth it.

Would a 1/4 scale be too small? 1/5? 1/6? What about small gassers? or even down to 1.20 or smaller birds?


Kaos Rulz 10-05-2007 11:13 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 
Thanks Bruce/da Rock,

Man you guys have very sharp eyes to have spotted that on the cover.

da Rock 10-05-2007 11:18 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: ED STEFAN

Thanks Bruce/da Rock,

Man you guys have very sharp eyes to have spotted that on the cover.

When you've been building and drawing your own for awhile, you realize that the details are what makes the differences. And you look for 'em like they were worth money to you.

da Rock 10-05-2007 11:29 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: vmsguy

I wonder if there's a practical size limit to using boost tabs.

By that I mean, when is a control surface (and by inference the plane) too small to make boost tabs not worth it.

Would a 1/4 scale be too small? 1/5? 1/6? What about small gassers? or even down to 1.20 or smaller birds?



It's actually fairly simple to establish the value of them for models.
With most of our popular, mass produced models, there will be one servo that is strong enough to drive one aileron. When we increase the size of that aileron beyond that requirement, the booster tab makes sense.

As for how small is the limit? We got servos for everything up to the big birds.

If you can drive all the surfaces with one servo each, that's the boundary.

I've never understood why there were and are so many, many big models that have 2, 3, and 4 servos on a tray driving just one rudder. And why so many elevators have 4 or ailerons use 4 or 6. Guess the manufacturers figure they sell more airplanes for 10-15% less to people who don't know there is a way the big bird they're buying could take 6 or 8 less servos.


vmsguy 10-05-2007 11:58 AM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: da Rock



ORIGINAL: vmsguy

I wonder if there's a practical size limit to using boost tabs.

By that I mean, when is a control surface (and by inference the plane) too small to make boost tabs not worth it.

Would a 1/4 scale be too small? 1/5? 1/6? What about small gassers? or even down to 1.20 or smaller birds?



It's actually fairly simple to establish the value of them for models.
With most of our popular, mass produced models, there will be one servo that is strong enough to drive one aileron. When we increase the size of that aileron beyond that requirement, the booster tab makes sense.

As for how small is the limit? We got servos for everything up to the big birds.

If you can drive all the surfaces with one servo each, that's the boundary.

I've never understood why there were and are so many, many big models that have 2, 3, and 4 servos on a tray driving just one rudder. And why so many elevators have 4 or ailerons use 4 or 6. Guess the manufacturers figure they sell more airplanes for 10-15% less to people who don't know there is a way the big bird they're buying could take 6 or 8 less servos.



I was thinking from an aerodynamic perspective. Can a smaller model gain agility with boost tabs without have to increase control surface size?

For example, can a big ol' trainer, that should really have a larger rudder area, gain rudder authority by just adding a boost tab to the rudder? Thus eliminating the need for possibly extensive modifications.





bruce88123 10-05-2007 01:02 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: vmsguy



ORIGINAL: da Rock



ORIGINAL: vmsguy

I wonder if there's a practical size limit to using boost tabs.

By that I mean, when is a control surface (and by inference the plane) too small to make boost tabs not worth it.

Would a 1/4 scale be too small? 1/5? 1/6? What about small gassers? or even down to 1.20 or smaller birds?



It's actually fairly simple to establish the value of them for models.
With most of our popular, mass produced models, there will be one servo that is strong enough to drive one aileron. When we increase the size of that aileron beyond that requirement, the booster tab makes sense.

As for how small is the limit? We got servos for everything up to the big birds.

If you can drive all the surfaces with one servo each, that's the boundary.

I've never understood why there were and are so many, many big models that have 2, 3, and 4 servos on a tray driving just one rudder. And why so many elevators have 4 or ailerons use 4 or 6. Guess the manufacturers figure they sell more airplanes for 10-15% less to people who don't know there is a way the big bird they're buying could take 6 or 8 less servos.



I was thinking from an aerodynamic perspective. Can a smaller model gain agility with boost tabs without have to increase control surface size?

For example, can a big ol' trainer, that should really have a larger rudder area, gain rudder authority by just adding a boost tab to the rudder? Thus eliminating the need for possibly extensive modifications.

No, it still takes surface area to deflect the air to move the plane. The boost tab just makes it easier to move the surface which then moves the plane.


Forgues Research 10-05-2007 05:50 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
You might want to go here for Boost Tabs


Roger

Forgues Research 10-05-2007 05:51 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 
They blocked the site

try Flying Giant

Roger

Stickbuilder 10-05-2007 08:10 PM

RE: How do they do that????
 


ORIGINAL: vmsguy

I wonder if there's a practical size limit to using boost tabs.

By that I mean, when is a control surface (and by inference the plane) too small to make boost tabs not worth it.

Would a 1/4 scale be too small? 1/5? 1/6? What about small gassers? or even down to 1.20 or smaller birds?


Yes, there is a prictical size limit to using boost tabs. They would need to be bigger than the control surfaces found on a 747 though.:D As I said, I use a boost tab that looks like the scale trim tab on the rudder of my scale WACO's. It works, and I can use a reasonable servo. If you are doing anything of at least a normal .40 size it will work fine too. In fact, you could use them on a 1/2A size. I wouldn't expect for them to have much value on the typical park flyer, due to the lack of speed with one of these. Air flow is the necessary force required for them to be effective.

Bill, AMA 4720
WACO Brotherhood #1


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:37 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.