stopping prop?
#1
Thread Starter

My Feedback: (12)
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 408
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ellicott City,
MD
I'm going to maiden a G.P. combat Corsairs {conversion} without LG. I need to know if I can make the prop stop Horizontal to the ground before I land it on grass... Thanks, Mikel-T
#2
Senior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 998
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Northern Occupied Mexico,
CA
If your ESC has a "Brake" then yes you can.
You will have to blip the throttle a couple of times get it lined up before touch down.
You will have to blip the throttle a couple of times get it lined up before touch down.
#4
Senior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 998
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Northern Occupied Mexico,
CA
Yes, I have a couple of foams that belly land and it usually only takes 3 or 4 blips until the prop stops horizontal.
On final approach there is plenty of time to get it just right.
On final approach there is plenty of time to get it just right.
#5

My Feedback: (2)
I agree, an ESC based brake will stop the prop but it will not align it with the ground. I am not aware of any device that stops the prop in a specific spot.
Many people who belly land use "prop savers" which use rubber o-rings to mount the prop.. There are a variety of companies that make them.
Many people who belly land use "prop savers" which use rubber o-rings to mount the prop.. There are a variety of companies that make them.
#6
Senior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 998
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Northern Occupied Mexico,
CA
I have seen a system in a sail plane with a retractable motor where the prop stops in the same orientation every time so it can be retracted.
Knowing the prices of these large sailplanes means it would be better to just buy a few hundred props and change them when needed.
Knowing the prices of these large sailplanes means it would be better to just buy a few hundred props and change them when needed.
#8
#10
hi there from Toledo
Back to the future
Okay, I have been flying epowered airplanes since before brushless motors, before lipos, and even before NIMH cells. So back in the prehistoric days to stop a prop was also a concern and since no ESC (and they were analog not digital!!) at the time had a brake function, you had to stop the prop mechanically.
How to stop a prop
What we did was to take a servo and a piece of nyrod and install the outer rod from the servo through the front firewall and past the motor stopping just behind the prop arc. The servo was connected to the retract channel and so was switchable. The inner nyrod was the attached to the servo arm in the usual manner and the length of the inner rod was adjusted so that the inner rod would extend just a little bit into the plane of the prop so that when extended the inner rod would interfere with the prop's rotation and buzz like a cicada if the power were on. If the motor was turned off and just freewheeling, this interference was enough to stop the prop and stop it in the same position every time. It saved props during landings without LG but you had to replace the inner nyrod every so often and it did scuff up the TE of the prop a little but so it goes.
This really worked quite well, give it a try.
ciao -rjf
Back to the future
Okay, I have been flying epowered airplanes since before brushless motors, before lipos, and even before NIMH cells. So back in the prehistoric days to stop a prop was also a concern and since no ESC (and they were analog not digital!!) at the time had a brake function, you had to stop the prop mechanically.
How to stop a prop
What we did was to take a servo and a piece of nyrod and install the outer rod from the servo through the front firewall and past the motor stopping just behind the prop arc. The servo was connected to the retract channel and so was switchable. The inner nyrod was the attached to the servo arm in the usual manner and the length of the inner rod was adjusted so that the inner rod would extend just a little bit into the plane of the prop so that when extended the inner rod would interfere with the prop's rotation and buzz like a cicada if the power were on. If the motor was turned off and just freewheeling, this interference was enough to stop the prop and stop it in the same position every time. It saved props during landings without LG but you had to replace the inner nyrod every so often and it did scuff up the TE of the prop a little but so it goes.
This really worked quite well, give it a try.
ciao -rjf
#11
Thread Starter

My Feedback: (12)
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 408
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ellicott City,
MD
Well Done my prehistoric friend....I was sure there was a bigger brain than mine out there
. Furthermore, I used to fly electrics before there were motors & batteries! they were called RUBBER BANDS! LOL THanks again for an ingeniuos solution!
. Furthermore, I used to fly electrics before there were motors & batteries! they were called RUBBER BANDS! LOL THanks again for an ingeniuos solution!




