3D giant comparisson planes
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ArlingtonVA
Im trying to learn more of 3d giant planes,a nd wanted ask your comparisson / pros and cons between these giant 3d planes:
yak 54, sukoi, extra 300/330
yak 54, sukoi, extra 300/330
#2
the yak 54 has a short fatter fuse and slightly more wing area.... from my experience they 3d very well, my pilot yak 54 is the best 3der i have flown.... i just wish it was a 100cc 
i have a 260 it does decent 3d but it the most precise flying plane i have every flown, other than a pattern plane
the MX2 IMO flys in between the yak54 and the 260
i used to have a WH baby edge 540 i dont know if it is a fair comparison since it was a 1.20 size but it flew the worst of them all... it had a horrible coupleing issue on knife edge
i wouldnt mind owning a bigger 50cc+ Edge 540 but im scared it will have the same bad characteristic ...

i have a 260 it does decent 3d but it the most precise flying plane i have every flown, other than a pattern plane
the MX2 IMO flys in between the yak54 and the 260
i used to have a WH baby edge 540 i dont know if it is a fair comparison since it was a 1.20 size but it flew the worst of them all... it had a horrible coupleing issue on knife edge
i wouldnt mind owning a bigger 50cc+ Edge 540 but im scared it will have the same bad characteristic ...
#3
Thread Starter

Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ArlingtonVA
MetallicaJunkie, do you think a 100cc would compronmise in any way the good quality characteristics of the Yak 54 ? perhaps cause of weight ?!
also - can anyone compare the Sukoi to the Yak 54 ?
also - can anyone compare the Sukoi to the Yak 54 ?
#4
100cc would bring out better flying characteristics of basically any scale aerobatic plane,especially when it come to IMAC/pattern and 3D planes ...imo 100cc is the biggest i would go personally and 50cc on up is where they really start to shine....after 100cc they almost double in price and become a pain in the @ass to transport...
bigger flys better in most cases... with the exception of a stick.... i like the maneuverability of a 40 size stick, but flew a giant gasser stick and it was a totally different animal, too tame for me.
bigger flys better in most cases... with the exception of a stick.... i like the maneuverability of a 40 size stick, but flew a giant gasser stick and it was a totally different animal, too tame for me.
#7
ORIGINAL: Whistling Death
Tbone , there is a huge forum on RCU for 3D planes. This is the gas engine forum.
Tbone , there is a huge forum on RCU for 3D planes. This is the gas engine forum.





