Thrustline centered in cowl?
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 293
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boise, ID
The plane has a built-in 2 degree firewall offset/angle to the right. If I center the engine on the firewall the engines thrust plate will not be centered at the front of the cowl. Theoretically it should be 2 degrees off center.
My question; is it ok to off-set the engine on the firewall to make the thrust plate centered in the cowl? This would slightly change the balance along the longitudinal axis but probably not very much.
Any opinions? Thanks.
PS; plane is a 26% CA Extra 330 with a DA 50.
My question; is it ok to off-set the engine on the firewall to make the thrust plate centered in the cowl? This would slightly change the balance along the longitudinal axis but probably not very much.
Any opinions? Thanks.
PS; plane is a 26% CA Extra 330 with a DA 50.
#2

My Feedback: (91)
Surf...I center my engine on my planes in the following manner. I take a "Step Ladder," and I place my airplane in a vertical position with the landing gear resting on the top of the ladder. I then place my engine on the firewall, and slip the cowl in the position, and move the engine around until I have the engine centered with the cowl. When it's centered I gently remove the cowl, without disturbing the position of the engine. Mark you holes for the bolts, and there you have it. Remember......when you shift the engine a little off center, The engine is still mostly centered because the crankshaft is in the proper alignment with the firewall and cowl. Your plane will never know the difference.
#3
Thread Starter

Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 293
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boise, ID
Bob,
Thanks. I just kinda did something similar. I can't put the cowl on because I need to cut it out for the cylinder head. What I did was tape a ruler down the center line and set the fus. vertically. Then I set the engine on the firewall and eyeballed the position laterally. I'm ok side to side, and the horizontal plane shouldn't change.
So it doesn't really matter the minor sideways offset. Thanks, Dan
Thanks. I just kinda did something similar. I can't put the cowl on because I need to cut it out for the cylinder head. What I did was tape a ruler down the center line and set the fus. vertically. Then I set the engine on the firewall and eyeballed the position laterally. I'm ok side to side, and the horizontal plane shouldn't change.
So it doesn't really matter the minor sideways offset. Thanks, Dan
#4
using a drafting triangle and a ruler - this all gets easy---
measure distance of spinner backplate to engine mounting plate (sometimes called firewall)
say it is 6"-
make a little 3" square plate of wood with a 6" long pointer exactly centered centered in it and perfectly vertical to the plate.
tape this to the firewall - add the cowl --then - using the ruler to check cowl lip-- get the pointer centered .
move the plate around and tape it as needed.
remove the cowl n mark the engine mounting plate to match the wood plate .
OR
You can use a sheetmetal layout protractor - and draw in various thrust angles to see how much mounting offset is needed -
When I am laying out a new design - I use the protractor . this gives firewall angle - engine offset etc..
for most jobs -- the little wood block works fine .
measure distance of spinner backplate to engine mounting plate (sometimes called firewall)
say it is 6"-
make a little 3" square plate of wood with a 6" long pointer exactly centered centered in it and perfectly vertical to the plate.
tape this to the firewall - add the cowl --then - using the ruler to check cowl lip-- get the pointer centered .
move the plate around and tape it as needed.
remove the cowl n mark the engine mounting plate to match the wood plate .
OR
You can use a sheetmetal layout protractor - and draw in various thrust angles to see how much mounting offset is needed -
When I am laying out a new design - I use the protractor . this gives firewall angle - engine offset etc..
for most jobs -- the little wood block works fine .
#5

My Feedback: (1)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 789
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: North Las VegasNV
What Bob Laine said only I mount the engine before I put the rudder on that way I can set the plane on its tail tape it to my bench and do what you said. 
Larry
I am watching you

Larry
I am watching you
#9
ORIGINAL: excaliber
forget the offset its an old wives tale. or just offset the rudder if you think its necessary.
geez
forget the offset its an old wives tale. or just offset the rudder if you think its necessary.
geez
I do it like this:
Figure out how long the engine will be from the firewall too the drive hub. Let's say 6.5"
Now, draw 2 parrallel lines on a sheet of paper 6.5" apart. One line on top of paper--one line on bottom.
Now draw a CL mark 90 degrees to the parrallel lines. You basically got an I-beam shape now.
Use a protractor on the 90 degree mark. Put the protractor on the bottom line and line it up with the 90 degree mark.
Now find the 2 or 3 degree mark on the protractor and put a mark on the top line.
The distance between the 90 degree mark and your 3 degree mark is how much you need to offset your engine.
Crude paint image attached:
#10
Thread Starter

Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 293
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boise, ID
Rcpilet, I know what you are saying but I was to lazy to figure out the trig. involved. I used a method similar to what Dick mentioned and it worked good.
I agree that offset is not a wives tale! Thanks all.
I agree that offset is not a wives tale! Thanks all.
#11
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Rock City, IL
$12 calculator, 2nd function, tan, enter thrust angle X distance from spinner face to firewall = offset distance. Thought you would never need that 8th grade math huh?
#12
A sheetmetal layout protractor is cheaper than a decent calculator --and a lot more accurate --in that you see the angle - rather than input (and get output) of incorrect numbers
Basically-it is a protractor with a long arm and the sheetmetal guys use em to layout and scribe lines for bending metal ' excellent model tool as it lets you accurately look at any angle .
Basically-it is a protractor with a long arm and the sheetmetal guys use em to layout and scribe lines for bending metal ' excellent model tool as it lets you accurately look at any angle .
#13
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Rock City, IL
Dick,
I am mentally challanged when it comes to using the sheet metal protracter, the one I have the square portion extends below the protractor. This for some reason causes a lack of visualation of how to properly lay out dimensions. It is much simpler for me to take the tangent of the desired angle times the distance from the prop hub to the fire wall. take this dimension and transfer it using dial calipers to the fire wall. If needed I can draw this out on paper. I guess each to his (her) own.
I am mentally challanged when it comes to using the sheet metal protracter, the one I have the square portion extends below the protractor. This for some reason causes a lack of visualation of how to properly lay out dimensions. It is much simpler for me to take the tangent of the desired angle times the distance from the prop hub to the fire wall. take this dimension and transfer it using dial calipers to the fire wall. If needed I can draw this out on paper. I guess each to his (her) own.
#14
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 361
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Copenhagen, DENMARK
ORIGINAL: Rcpilet
I hope your kidding. Engine thrust is not a wives tale.
ORIGINAL: excaliber
forget the offset its an old wives tale. or just offset the rudder if you think its necessary.
geez
forget the offset its an old wives tale. or just offset the rudder if you think its necessary.
geez
Chip Hyde, is the most renowned advocate of this methode instead of offsetting the engine.
#15
I use mine -- sometimes by simply drawing a squared T on my table top (glass)- then noting prop to mount distance on the vertical leg of the T.
The layout tool -set to degrees noted as offset- (pointing to spinner c/l)--will then easily show what the offset mounting distance is from C/L .
The layout tool -set to degrees noted as offset- (pointing to spinner c/l)--will then easily show what the offset mounting distance is from C/L .
#17
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 299
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: metropolis, ANTARCTICA
RCpilot, don't confuse THRUST with TORQUE or P-FACTOR
I still set my planes up, (aerobatic) at Zero degrees on the engine aas well as the wings, horizontal and rudder.
And some of the hotshot pilots that flown my planes have not noticed the difference.
I'm not trying to convert anyonebut it works for me, in patern or IMAC
I still set my planes up, (aerobatic) at Zero degrees on the engine aas well as the wings, horizontal and rudder.
And some of the hotshot pilots that flown my planes have not noticed the difference.
I'm not trying to convert anyonebut it works for me, in patern or IMAC




