FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Sandy,
UT
Posts: 805
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Sorry if this has been gone over I couldn't find it in a search, I am curious what folks are thinking of this Engine?
$200.00 is pretty good for 45CC, or is it too good to be true?
I currently fly gliders but I was toying with getting back into a powered plane like that Honda Scheme Wild Hare 87" Sukhoi SU-26
Tom
$200.00 is pretty good for 45CC, or is it too good to be true?
I currently fly gliders but I was toying with getting back into a powered plane like that Honda Scheme Wild Hare 87" Sukhoi SU-26
Tom
#3
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Not sure about an FRL45 but here is an FTL 45 https://www.unitedhobbies.com/UNITED...idProduct=5460
#4
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Makes sense, I do typos all the time, so that prolly covers it. I don't believe there has been anything definitive on this engine yet but te price is good enough to try it if you have the talent to work with a gasser a little.
#6
Senior Member
My Feedback: (24)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: AUBURN,
GA
Posts: 1,323
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Thought I would give one a try but only got one flight with it and the ignition went out on it, Was getting 7080 RPM with a pro zinger 20-10 prop running a little rich.
I think one of the main problems will be getting service for the engine, Got in touch with United Hobby and they sent a a address in North Carolina to send it. Sent with delivery no and they received a week ago and still have not heard anything about it. Going on three weeks now with no ignition. Looks like if I get to use the engine will have to go th CH and get a new ignition.
Milton
I think one of the main problems will be getting service for the engine, Got in touch with United Hobby and they sent a a address in North Carolina to send it. Sent with delivery no and they received a week ago and still have not heard anything about it. Going on three weeks now with no ignition. Looks like if I get to use the engine will have to go th CH and get a new ignition.
Milton
#7
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
It's easy to see now (with hindsight) how a $199 (plus freight) engine works out to be worse value than something "tried and tested" such as the incredible DL50 ($370 shipped).
Although the FRL45 is $150 or so cheaper on paper, by the time you dick-around getting it going and *keeping* it going, your costs are probably not going to be very much (if any) less than had you bought a "known quantity" like the DL.
The DL also has *stacks* more power and local (to the USA) support that (going by all reports) is first-rate.
I (like you) have been burnt before by taking a punt on a "cheap" engine. Now I wait for others to make the mistakes so I can spend my money more wisely :-)
Although the FRL45 is $150 or so cheaper on paper, by the time you dick-around getting it going and *keeping* it going, your costs are probably not going to be very much (if any) less than had you bought a "known quantity" like the DL.
The DL also has *stacks* more power and local (to the USA) support that (going by all reports) is first-rate.
I (like you) have been burnt before by taking a punt on a "cheap" engine. Now I wait for others to make the mistakes so I can spend my money more wisely :-)
#8
Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: wedowee,
AL
Posts: 95
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
XJET, you are right on target, I bought a CRRC Pro 45cc engine, was only good for a boat anchor. The DL 50 is a tried a proven product, price is more than right. I own two of them and several DA's. You cannot beat the realibility, performance and the price on the DL.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: West Elelizabeth,
PA
Posts: 157
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
I dont know why ppl are puting down the CRRC 45 I have two of them and a Thor 45 and all three run very well with not one problem with at the min. of 5gal in each one.
#11
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
ORIGINAL: mitchmcf
I dont know why ppl are puting down the CRRC 45 I have two of them and a Thor 45 and all three run very well with not one problem with at the min. of 5gal in each one.
I dont know why ppl are puting down the CRRC 45 I have two of them and a Thor 45 and all three run very well with not one problem with at the min. of 5gal in each one.
(And no, it's not my only gasser so I'm not speaking from ignorance of how these things are supposed to work or how to set them up.
They're a lottery -- some (no doubt) perform well (like yours) but there are a *lot* of others that come out of the factory in a state that is sorely deficient. Mine wouldn't even turn over because the crank wasn't pressed together properly so the bearings had bound up.
There are quite a few similar tales of woe from owners who have converted their CRRC engines into delightful paperweights - or anchors for a bit of bass-fishing.
#12
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
or anchors for a bit of bass-fishing.
#13
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: ,
Posts: 10
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
mitchmcf
I think the key of your question is,Xjet own an eld type of GF45I which quality is not as good as present.
The Thor45 and the latest GF45I were updated a lots.
LoL~~~
I think the key of your question is,Xjet own an eld type of GF45I which quality is not as good as present.
The Thor45 and the latest GF45I were updated a lots.
LoL~~~
#14
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Mine was the version with the new style muffler and new intake adaptor, not the older one with the wrap-around muffler and the leaky intake manifold. What's newer than that?
#16
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Tokoroa, , NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
I have the old ignition -- but with a munted crankshaft and bearings (out of the box) no amount of updating of the ignition is going to make it run sweetly (or at all) :-(
CRRCPro have *lousy* quality control so buying one is/was a lottery.
I've yet to see a dud DL50, the QC there seems better and they're just in a whole different league performance-wise. Plus, you don't have the hassle of an awkward side-mounted carby to deal with.
CRRCPro have *lousy* quality control so buying one is/was a lottery.
I've yet to see a dud DL50, the QC there seems better and they're just in a whole different league performance-wise. Plus, you don't have the hassle of an awkward side-mounted carby to deal with.
#18
My Feedback: (7)
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Bradford, Ohio
Posts: 397
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Just got mine. Opened the box, unmistakable gas smell-----this engine has definetely been run!! Good surprise.
Mounted it on a test stand, threw a 5 cell pack at the ignition, choke closed, handful of flips got a POP, choke open, couple flips later, purring away at a fast idle. Gave it some throttle, took it immediately (great transition!!). OK, I'm starting to like what I'm seeing. Full throttle, 6600 RPM with a 21 x 8 Xoar prop. Smooth. Not particularly quiet, but smooth. Of course, I'm not one to trust "factory" needle settings, so I proceed to adjust the card right out of adjustment. It was right where it needed to be out of the box!!! I've never seen this in a gasser before, and yep, I've owned/operated quite a few through the years. Got the idle slowed down nicely(removed the spring loaded idle stop screw as usual).
Now, this is only after about 20 minutes of bench running time, but if this thing continues to behave like this, I'll be a happy camper----
Mounted it on a test stand, threw a 5 cell pack at the ignition, choke closed, handful of flips got a POP, choke open, couple flips later, purring away at a fast idle. Gave it some throttle, took it immediately (great transition!!). OK, I'm starting to like what I'm seeing. Full throttle, 6600 RPM with a 21 x 8 Xoar prop. Smooth. Not particularly quiet, but smooth. Of course, I'm not one to trust "factory" needle settings, so I proceed to adjust the card right out of adjustment. It was right where it needed to be out of the box!!! I've never seen this in a gasser before, and yep, I've owned/operated quite a few through the years. Got the idle slowed down nicely(removed the spring loaded idle stop screw as usual).
Now, this is only after about 20 minutes of bench running time, but if this thing continues to behave like this, I'll be a happy camper----
#19
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Grand Paririe,
TX
Posts: 188
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
I have one coming, should be here by end fo week, Ill try to remember to post my findings ....... working on a plane to put it in, maybe a hangar 9 extra 260 which ive seen fly on a da50 ..........
#20
Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Kristiansand, NORWAY
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
I am considering this engine for a Pilatus Porter 2,40meter tow plane.
Please keep the reports coming
What´s the actual weight for FTL45 muffler and ignition included?
Please keep the reports coming
What´s the actual weight for FTL45 muffler and ignition included?
#21
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Grand Paririe,
TX
Posts: 188
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
I ordered it Thursday and got it tuesday, not bad for Hong Kong to Texas USA.
Ive not run it yet but may have found a plane for it.
Ive only weighted it complete in box, Includes motor, muffler, large tool, spark pug and included spark plug tool 4.14 pounds.
As everyone has said the muffler isnt anything pretty however the part that would usually show is ok, in a cowl the heavy welds wont show also i think the muffler is probally REALLY strong as the welds at thick and have not been grinded down like most are.
Motor has double rings on the piston, has Walbro carb and Electronic ignition that looks very simnilar to DA, it says its auto advancing and has a good quality cap on the lead for the Plug.
Once you set the choke it turns off when you throttle up automatically, Nice i think. ( easy to disable if you dont want)
Hopefully ill get to fly it soon, im very anxious and ill report props and rpm and other comments.
In looking at the motor i cant find anything that would make me think bad.
I have 2 DA's and there certinally great but I think this one might compare well ........
Dave
Ive not run it yet but may have found a plane for it.
Ive only weighted it complete in box, Includes motor, muffler, large tool, spark pug and included spark plug tool 4.14 pounds.
As everyone has said the muffler isnt anything pretty however the part that would usually show is ok, in a cowl the heavy welds wont show also i think the muffler is probally REALLY strong as the welds at thick and have not been grinded down like most are.
Motor has double rings on the piston, has Walbro carb and Electronic ignition that looks very simnilar to DA, it says its auto advancing and has a good quality cap on the lead for the Plug.
Once you set the choke it turns off when you throttle up automatically, Nice i think. ( easy to disable if you dont want)
Hopefully ill get to fly it soon, im very anxious and ill report props and rpm and other comments.
In looking at the motor i cant find anything that would make me think bad.
I have 2 DA's and there certinally great but I think this one might compare well ........
Dave
#22
Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Kristiansand, NORWAY
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Thank you for the report..
Please keep up the good work, would really appreciate as much info as possible before ordering.
Hope your engine runs as smooth as it looks
Best regards
JoE
Norway
Please keep up the good work, would really appreciate as much info as possible before ordering.
Hope your engine runs as smooth as it looks
Best regards
JoE
Norway
#23
Senior Member
My Feedback: (24)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: AUBURN,
GA
Posts: 1,323
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Posted this same statement on another site
Orderd one of the FTL45 and CRRC 45 and 26.
A lot of the parts will interchange from the CRRP and FTL45. One big differnce is the FTL comes with RC Xel ignition and the CRRP comes with ?
Like I posted earler the first ignition I got with the FTL was one of the older ones and went out on 6 volts, It took a month but was repalced by UH.
The FTL has a machined lower end and the CRRP has a cast lower end.
Both ignitions for the 26 and 45 for the CRRP went out on test stand so I repalced the 45 with a RC xel and got it running, Had to change maginet and sensor,
The stock igniton on the CRRP is fixed timing and makes it shake while at lower RPM.
All in all I think the FTL is a better engine than the CRRP, At least it is a better bang for the buck, Might be trouble to get warrnty work for it but that is the case for the CRRP also.
The 26 came with the threaded part of prop shaft bent and I put it in my lath and with a slite tap got it working, The metal is very shoft and easy to bend.
Milton
Orderd one of the FTL45 and CRRC 45 and 26.
A lot of the parts will interchange from the CRRP and FTL45. One big differnce is the FTL comes with RC Xel ignition and the CRRP comes with ?
Like I posted earler the first ignition I got with the FTL was one of the older ones and went out on 6 volts, It took a month but was repalced by UH.
The FTL has a machined lower end and the CRRP has a cast lower end.
Both ignitions for the 26 and 45 for the CRRP went out on test stand so I repalced the 45 with a RC xel and got it running, Had to change maginet and sensor,
The stock igniton on the CRRP is fixed timing and makes it shake while at lower RPM.
All in all I think the FTL is a better engine than the CRRP, At least it is a better bang for the buck, Might be trouble to get warrnty work for it but that is the case for the CRRP also.
The 26 came with the threaded part of prop shaft bent and I put it in my lath and with a slite tap got it working, The metal is very shoft and easy to bend.
Milton
#24
Junior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Glenrock , WY
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: FRL45 Gas engine Whats the verdict?
Need help
received my FTL 45 gasoline engine a couple of days ago. I did not receive as spark plug with it. I would like to know what spark plug to use with it. Something that would be available champion,NKG in the US. I have e-mailed them several times I got replies but not answers. This engine looks very good I hope it runs as good as it looks. The instruction manual is a total waste and there are no directions with the electronic ignition. I am going to put it in a 33% Pitts special from RC guys they had a special on the plane so I decided to try it. $500 for plane and engine is cheap. Thanks in advance for any help I get or words of wisdom.
Bob G.
received my FTL 45 gasoline engine a couple of days ago. I did not receive as spark plug with it. I would like to know what spark plug to use with it. Something that would be available champion,NKG in the US. I have e-mailed them several times I got replies but not answers. This engine looks very good I hope it runs as good as it looks. The instruction manual is a total waste and there are no directions with the electronic ignition. I am going to put it in a 33% Pitts special from RC guys they had a special on the plane so I decided to try it. $500 for plane and engine is cheap. Thanks in advance for any help I get or words of wisdom.
Bob G.