Anomie

Maybe Syesha vs. Archuleta, but I think Syesha vs. Cook is more likely in the end. At this point, it really doesn't matter anymore.

Does anyone else want to see Ryan voted off??

iamnot

like him or not
and i don't
you gotta give ryan credit
he turned a flakey co-host job
on a start-up talent show
into one mega career

i'd almost bet he outlasts simon

Anomie

True, he has done a great job of building a career (and I secretly love the way he says 'THIS... is American Idol')

Simon is far more powerful in the industry, smugness included.

Edit: I can't believe I posted a typo.

iamnot

well, that's true
i was mostly being factious

wasn't the core idol idea
simon's
i know that idol
was big in britan
before it ever got here

Anomie

Yeah, I think it was Simon and another co-creator on the American version. He has certainly capitalized on the television market for this vein of entertainment. I believe the UK version is called 'Pop Idol'.

iamnot

i think i'll stand by that predicrion
the way simon is fawning over da
i'm wondering if the rumors
of a fix
are true

don't be surprised
to see cook go next

god i hope i'm wrong

Anomie

You know, it doesn't matter anymore. I'm glad Jason was shown the door, but realistically the best talent has been gone for two weeks.

I thought Syesha did well on both songs, but Archuleta will likely prevail.

Anomie

So Parvati took the cash. I haven't watched it yet, but saw the headline. In a way, I'm happy for her - she really played everyone.

AI tonight, but I think it's going to be crappy anyway.

Who started this thread, anyway? [X(]

brett65

My Feedback: (18)

Cook rocks, he is from Oklahoma, but doesn't live here now.

Anomie

I agree. David Cook has done the best job of making each tune 'his own', as Simon would state, and also has demonstrated excellent vocals from the beginning. Other than Carly, I think he's the best.

It may end up Cook vs. Archuleta in the end. Tonight will be pivotal, maybe

Lightfoot

My Feedback: (1)

Cook excelled tonight. At this point, I don't see how he can lose but the majority of America could disagree.

Anomie

True, he was at the top of his game once again. Like Simon once stated - the outcome would be different if it weren't a popularity contest.

brett65

My Feedback: (18)

From what I have heard about the 2nd and 3rd place guys that were actually good, it's not that bad to not win the idol. Look at Chris Daughtry vs. Whathisname with the gray hair. I don't even remember his name and haven't seen anything or heard anything about him. Daughtry is everywhere, and even got Slash to play on his first album.

iamnot

yep, i agree

the show may be a popularity contest
but when it comes to
music actually being played

the talent wins out
and gets air time
long after the "winner" is
forgotten

ferrarimk13

i think cirie shouldve won survivor, she always made me laugh, and shes so damn smart. She played everyone in both seasons. Parvati is just like she seems, ****ty, but i guess she played well, I cant believe how stupid eric was [:@]

Anomie

Eric was a bonehead, especially after watching Ozzy THEN Jason THEN James being chopped.

I'm just glad Natalie didn't go any further. She was such a hag since the merge, and I just wanted to push her over in the sand [:'(]

Cirie had been good at manipulating others, for sure. She could have pulled it out at the end I guess.

Who is leaving AI tonight? Hmm...

iamnot

woo hoo
kristy won dwts
that makes me
two for three
i got bb and dwts
and of course carley is out of ai

maybe my second choice
david cook
will get the win

sure hope it's not
david a

if cook wins
or even if he doesn't
he will be big

archuleta, if he wins,
will be a shooting star
bright at first
and soon forgotten

brett65

My Feedback: (18)

I was wrong, David Cook is from MO, but now lives in Tulsa. Of course now I'm sure he will be moving. His album should rock!

qaiz

Great ending.

Not what I expected, but better .