Considering switching to brushless from nitro, need pros and cons
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
Okay guys, I've been running nitro for the last two years and I'm about had it to HERE with them. To be fair my tuning skills are more to blame than the engines. I'm considering converting one of my buggies to brushless. I need to know the pros and cons from people who have actually converted to brushles from nitro. Take the "Nitro ROCKS" and "ELECTRIC SUKS" general comments to another forum. I'm trying to keep the content useful. Thanks for your input.
#2
The only quantifiable "con" to an electric conversion is initial cost... Unless you buy the cheap chinese batteries/chargers. If you stick with name-brand stuff, it gets expensive quick. The other cons are merely subjective like the lack of noise and the smell of nitro (which is actually a pro in many peoples' eyes).
Electrics are faster, cleaner and quieter. But for me, I like nitro because of the added challenge of tuning an engine. To me, a gas/nitro engine is what makes this hobby more of a true motorsport rather than just another hobby like stamp collecting
Electrics are faster, cleaner and quieter. But for me, I like nitro because of the added challenge of tuning an engine. To me, a gas/nitro engine is what makes this hobby more of a true motorsport rather than just another hobby like stamp collecting
#3
Junior Member
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 6
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Tallahassee,
FL
I was in your same position a couple months ago.........decided to sell all my nitro stuff and went brushless everything and from my experince with the new brushless stuff I can tell you I dont think ill ever own another nitro car again. No tuning, glo plugs, clutch shoes, smelling like nitro after you get done driving it and all the other stuff that comes along with nitro cars. Just charge and go.....and brushless cars will smoke a nitro car....its the wave of the future.
#4
until you run out of batteries than you get to sit and watch the nitros drive 
and before I'm called a hater I own a brushless setup (just its not in anything since it snapped my one buggy in two), a few brushed, and 2 nitros (soon to be 3 once my jammin arrives) so I got plenty of each type
but yes if you hate tuning than go electric. Also the cheap $20 lipo batteries are probably assembled in the same factory, by the same little kids in china as those nice expensive $100 lipos
the pro's and cons hmm I did a 1/10th ST from nitro to electric the only con I can think of is if you don't buy a conversion kit (or they don't make one in my case) trying to find a motor mount and pinion to fit the spur gear is a royal pain in the ass. Pro probably cheaper and more durable than a dedicated electric vehicle (this can change depending on what you have and use)

and before I'm called a hater I own a brushless setup (just its not in anything since it snapped my one buggy in two), a few brushed, and 2 nitros (soon to be 3 once my jammin arrives) so I got plenty of each type

but yes if you hate tuning than go electric. Also the cheap $20 lipo batteries are probably assembled in the same factory, by the same little kids in china as those nice expensive $100 lipos

the pro's and cons hmm I did a 1/10th ST from nitro to electric the only con I can think of is if you don't buy a conversion kit (or they don't make one in my case) trying to find a motor mount and pinion to fit the spur gear is a royal pain in the ass. Pro probably cheaper and more durable than a dedicated electric vehicle (this can change depending on what you have and use)
#6
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
Thanks.
I need to clarify.
I'm intrigued on how I could run two batteries in parellel as well as what is the best battery size/ESC/motor combo to go with. I'm leaning toward getting the Tekin V3 RC8T conversion kit and building from there. I like to keep mechanical brakes and a clutch to increase tunability.
Bear in mind that I know NOTHING about lipo. I'm trying to read up and talk to people who have been there and done that to get smart.
I need to clarify.
I'm intrigued on how I could run two batteries in parellel as well as what is the best battery size/ESC/motor combo to go with. I'm leaning toward getting the Tekin V3 RC8T conversion kit and building from there. I like to keep mechanical brakes and a clutch to increase tunability.
Bear in mind that I know NOTHING about lipo. I'm trying to read up and talk to people who have been there and done that to get smart.
#7
my opinion is brushless belongs on touring cars and small scale R/c's.
its big money for brushless, plus you have to wait for it to charge after a run.
i mean yeah, they can move out really well, but the setup is heavier.
in all its up to you, not having to tune is nice, charging sucks, paying for fuel sucks too, the sound and smell is energizing, but it can leave you with watery eyes, electric is quiet and you will miss that sound. electric has a "toyish" feel to it, but nitro is messy.
its big money for brushless, plus you have to wait for it to charge after a run.
i mean yeah, they can move out really well, but the setup is heavier.
in all its up to you, not having to tune is nice, charging sucks, paying for fuel sucks too, the sound and smell is energizing, but it can leave you with watery eyes, electric is quiet and you will miss that sound. electric has a "toyish" feel to it, but nitro is messy.
#8
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
I saw this one for sale. Take a look and give me your thoughts. It's a Rc8t limited edition converted to electric with the elite rc mount and elite rc battery trays i flipped the motor around to run saddle pack it also has the bce chassis and the factory team spindles / knuckles
and factory team rear uprights and and the factory team aluminum stub axles and the factory team toe blocks and titanium nitride hinge pins all hop ups are new never used except for chassis it also has a tekin rx8 esc and a tekin t8 2000kv truggy motor and a custom esc and servo mount.





Should I jump on this one. It runs dual batteries like I want to do
and factory team rear uprights and and the factory team aluminum stub axles and the factory team toe blocks and titanium nitride hinge pins all hop ups are new never used except for chassis it also has a tekin rx8 esc and a tekin t8 2000kv truggy motor and a custom esc and servo mount.





Should I jump on this one. It runs dual batteries like I want to do
#10
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: INTEGRA
that is a NIIIIIICE set-up...i vote pick it up asap.
But Un pinch the red splitter wire.
that is a NIIIIIICE set-up...i vote pick it up asap.
But Un pinch the red splitter wire.
Tekno RC V3 Brushless Kit for Associated RC8T/SC8 (42mm Castle/Tekin Motors)
Castle Creations Mamba Monster 1/8th Scale Brushless Car Package (2200kV)
Hyperion EOS 0615i 6S Duo III Balancing Charger
Team Losi LiPo Protection Pouch, Large (qty 2)
#11
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Wpg,
MB, CANADA
Tekin if it were me.....im personally not a fan of the tekno Chassis or clutch...more stuff to worry about that isn't needed.
615i is right on the money.
615i is right on the money.
#14
Senior Member
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 1,968
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: antwerpen, BELGIUM
Go for it. Looks like a very nice set up.
Does it come complete with charger and battery packs??? If so its a pretty good deal.
Does it come complete with charger and battery packs??? If so its a pretty good deal.
#15
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
I called the guy and he said he would call me back which he never did. I'm not chasing somebody down to give them my money. It would be cheaper for me to convert my Nitro RC8T using the same setup and everything would be new. So I'm looking to order everything I need and do the build myself.
#16
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 930
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: statham, GA
ORIGINAL: El Tigre
I called the guy and he said he would call me back which he never did. I'm not chasing somebody down to give them my money. It would be cheaper for me to convert my Nitro RC8T using the same setup and everything would be new. So I'm looking to order everything I need and do the build myself.
I called the guy and he said he would call me back which he never did. I'm not chasing somebody down to give them my money. It would be cheaper for me to convert my Nitro RC8T using the same setup and everything would be new. So I'm looking to order everything I need and do the build myself.
<br type="_moz" />
#17
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: jmaxey51
I think that is a smart move because you will know exactly what you have and you know it will last and its not some worn out crap.
<br type=''_moz'' />
ORIGINAL: El Tigre
I called the guy and he said he would call me back which he never did. I'm not chasing somebody down to give them my money. It would be cheaper for me to convert my Nitro RC8T using the same setup and everything would be new. So I'm looking to order everything I need and do the build myself.
I called the guy and he said he would call me back which he never did. I'm not chasing somebody down to give them my money. It would be cheaper for me to convert my Nitro RC8T using the same setup and everything would be new. So I'm looking to order everything I need and do the build myself.
<br type=''_moz'' />
Castle Creations Mamba Monster 1/8th Scale Brushless Car Package (2200kV)
Elite RC ERC-RC8 Motor Mount
2x Tekno RC V3 Battery Tray (150x50mm)
2x Tekno RC Battery Straps (black
2x Traxxas Connector Set (Male/Female)
4x ZIPPY Flightmax 5000mAh 4S1P 40C batteries
I'm also getting the Hyperion EOS 0615i 6S Duo III Balancing Charger for $269.99 but I'm not including it in the build cost
#19
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: INTEGRA
cough*cough* Tekin cough* cough*
cough*cough* Tekin cough* cough*
I would be hard press to believe that if I drove the Tekin and then drove the Mamba that I would say "DAMN, I can see why the Tekin cost $90 more." If there is that big a speed difference then if would be WAY too much power to control during a race cause I know that the Mamba's haul much assz
cough*cough* I can use that extra money for batteries. cough*cough*
#20
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
#21
Nitro's are still getting the fastest laps on most tracks guys....so BL doesn't smoke Nitro when it comes to racing ...BL will never take over nitro ! I have no issue with BL, i even race a BL car, but the reality is BL will always be nothing more then a fringe interest next to nitro..
#22
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: supertib
Nitro's are still getting the fastest laps on most tracks guys....so BL doesn't smoke Nitro when it comes to racing ...BL will never take over nitro ! I have no issue with BL, i even race a BL car, but the reality is BL will always be nothing more then a fringe interest next to nitro..
Nitro's are still getting the fastest laps on most tracks guys....so BL doesn't smoke Nitro when it comes to racing ...BL will never take over nitro ! I have no issue with BL, i even race a BL car, but the reality is BL will always be nothing more then a fringe interest next to nitro..
#23
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: supertib
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
#24
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Wpg,
MB, CANADA
ORIGINAL: El Tigre
Can you clarify what you mean when you say the MM feel terrible at low speeds, is it jerky? is it like two speeds, stand still and full throttle? with no midrange in between? Help me understand. While I won't pay extra for speed, I will pay extra for drivability.
ORIGINAL: supertib
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
right on the money tigre......the CC system hits like a Brick Shi* house off the bottom end...there's no linear feel to it what so ever and feels overly dull off the jumps.....the tekin is WELL worth the extra 90$....every time i drive a CC system im reminded of how glad i am i wen t with the Tekin.
Supertib is defending his Nitro background and stating facts.....he's sick of the BL bandwagon stating things like " nitro is a thing of the past" and " Nitro motors have peaked in performance and wont get any better. or " BL beat's nitro around the track all the time" when its simple Not the case.
#25
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Locust Grove, GA
ORIGINAL: INTEGRA
right on the money tigre......the CC system hits like a Brick Shi* house off the bottom end...there's no linear feel to it what so ever and feels overly dull off the jumps.....the tekin is WELL worth the extra 90$....every time i drive a CC system im reminded of how glad i am i wen t with the Tekin.
Supertib is defending his Nitro background and stating facts.....he's sick of the BL bandwagon stating things like '' nitro is a thing of the past'' and '' Nitro motors have peaked in performance and wont get any better. or '' BL beat's nitro around the track all the time'' when its simple Not the case.
ORIGINAL: El Tigre
Can you clarify what you mean when you say the MM feel terrible at low speeds, is it jerky? is it like two speeds, stand still and full throttle? with no midrange in between? Help me understand. While I won't pay extra for speed, I will pay extra for drivability.
ORIGINAL: supertib
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
Tekin is so much smoother at low speeds then the MM...night and day difference..... the MM feel terrible off the jumps and in the infield...the Tekin is far superior to race with IMO.....
right on the money tigre......the CC system hits like a Brick Shi* house off the bottom end...there's no linear feel to it what so ever and feels overly dull off the jumps.....the tekin is WELL worth the extra 90$....every time i drive a CC system im reminded of how glad i am i wen t with the Tekin.
Supertib is defending his Nitro background and stating facts.....he's sick of the BL bandwagon stating things like '' nitro is a thing of the past'' and '' Nitro motors have peaked in performance and wont get any better. or '' BL beat's nitro around the track all the time'' when its simple Not the case.
I got that Supertib is defending Nitro, I'm not saying that BL is faster than Nitro. They can be the same speed for all I care. I will say that BL is WAY less labor intensive to prep for a race than Nitro. I travel 50% out of the state and when I return Friday night for a race Saturday morning, I only want to plug in my batteries and be done with it.
Anywho I started this thread to learn more about BL from those with more experience like yourself, not bash nitro or defend BL. So generic "ELECTRIC SUKS, NITRO RUES" comments don't help me learn and can go on another thread.



