HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
#1
Thread Starter
HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
I have run some un-scientific checks on the maximum speeds of my HL tanks.
I think these are close to original, maximum speeds for these tanks.
If I have not made an error, they are;
Panther G, Jagpanther, Stug III (all stock) ; Approx 24 Scale MPH
Tiger I (MATO 3:1, stock tracks, wheels, Suspension) Approx 17 Scale MPH
I think these are close to original, maximum speeds for these tanks.
The methodology;
I had a 20 ft clear run in my cluttered basement; There is nothing special about 20 ft., it was what I had available at the time.
At 1/16 scale, 20 "real" feet represents 320 scale feet
Tiger I took 13 seconds to run this which works out to 24.615 Scale Feet per second
24.615 FPS x 60 sec/min x 60 min./hr divided by 5280 ft/mile = 16.78 Scale MPH
This can be simplified as taking the number of seconds your tank takes to run 20 feet; call it “T’
320/T x .6818 = Scale MPH
Example
My Panther G took 9 seconds to cover 20 (real) feet
320/9 x .6818 = 24.24 Scale MPH
#3
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
A+ for math.
#4
Thread Starter
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
ORIGINAL: Pah co chu puk
A+ for math.
A+ for math.
I was surprised by the stock HL Panther and Stug speeds coming out close to the historical values; I always thought the stock HL's were too fast, at lease these varients don't seem to be.
The 3:1's have been great additon to my Tiger I., I think the stock HL Tiger might be too fast but I am not putting the stock gear boxes back in to test it
#5
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
As I recall, the Panther, Tiger, Panzer III/IV all ran within a couple of mph of each other...right around 25 mph. But, that was top speed on the road and generally wasn't sustained because of the wear and tear on the tanks. Your Tiger's speed is more correct for the upper end of the sustained road speeds in a road march.
#6
Thread Starter
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
ORIGINAL: philipat
As I recall, the Panther, Tiger, Panzer III/IV all ran within a couple of mph of each other...right around 25 mph. But, that was top speed on the road and generally wasn't sustained because of the wear and tear on the tanks.
As I recall, the Panther, Tiger, Panzer III/IV all ran within a couple of mph of each other...right around 25 mph. But, that was top speed on the road and generally wasn't sustained because of the wear and tear on the tanks.
#9
Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Tallahassee, FL
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
or just take the real speed of a tank divide that by 16 and you'll get the top scale speed of the model which represents the real tanks top speed
I've seen two different specs for the real tiger's speed one of them being 23mph
So at 23 mph divided by 16 gives you: 1.4375. This would be the top speed of your 1/16th tiger in scale speed.
I've seen two different specs for the real tiger's speed one of them being 23mph
So at 23 mph divided by 16 gives you: 1.4375. This would be the top speed of your 1/16th tiger in scale speed.
#10
Senior Member
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
This tank speed chart might be helpful as well: http://www.rcacn.org/ It is found under "Rules for Engagement" Along with tank speed listings & times.
If your tank is too fast you can always try a smaller pinion gear as opposed to a new gear box. It is cheaper alternative and easier most of the time. Slight modifications may be required to move the motor closer to the first gear. Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
Good luck, Bob
If your tank is too fast you can always try a smaller pinion gear as opposed to a new gear box. It is cheaper alternative and easier most of the time. Slight modifications may be required to move the motor closer to the first gear. Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
Good luck, Bob
#11
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
ORIGINAL: thecommander
Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
#12
Senior Member
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
ORIGINAL: philipat
Interesting hint...do you smash the paper between the two gears where they mesh?
ORIGINAL: thecommander
Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
Here is a hint: Use a strip of paper inserted between these two gears to set the proper clearance.
#13
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
Off road speeds are usually more a result of the local AO than true 'what it will do in the mud' speeds. Remember, tanks, especially buttoned up for combat, are essentially blind. The driver can often not see that nasty 3 m deep gulch until he is on it. If the commander also doesn't see it, then someone's ride is going to the body and fender shop asap if the tanque is bucketing across the veldt at a more than prudent speed. Good recon was also a must when possible without getting your tail feathers shot off.
#14
Thread Starter
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
ORIGINAL: thecommander
This tank speed chart might be helpful as well: http://www.rcacn.org/ It is found under "Rules for Engagement" Along with tank speed listings & times.
This tank speed chart might be helpful as well: http://www.rcacn.org/ It is found under "Rules for Engagement" Along with tank speed listings & times.
That's a good resource and it agrees with my figures when I correct them for the 25 ft test run, because I used 20 feet
I printed the chart for future reference, I'll just have to clear another 5 feet of "test track".
Thanks for posting that.
#16
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
Did you get any video of the tank on the treadmill?
#17
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
nah no video. dident think it was somthing any one would really wanna watch : )
also its how i adjust the esc to make the tank run in a straight line.
also its how i adjust the esc to make the tank run in a straight line.
#18
Senior Member
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
Agree whole heartedly, The M-41 pioneered the new larger persicopes, so the driver didn't have that 1 x 6 inch prism stuck nearly on his nose. But in spite of all, cross country was a slow process and totally guesswork over some terrain. This was complicated more by "new" IR periscopes which made it impossible for judging distance in any way. Many teeth were lost and nose injuries were caused by speeding over a field.
Speed was generally far below max, particularly on German tanks. They were notoriously weak and prone to breaking. Not all spares were there for added armor...they were needed. American design tracks are the best.
Speed was generally far below max, particularly on German tanks. They were notoriously weak and prone to breaking. Not all spares were there for added armor...they were needed. American design tracks are the best.
#19
Thread Starter
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
Update, for general interest.
A new HL Tiger I with the original metal (not 3:1's) ran the 20 foot distance in 9 seconds, indicating a scale 24 MPH.
This is going to be the new "project", it will be gettting 3:1's to address the speed and improove driveability, and have an SLU installed.
A new HL Tiger I with the original metal (not 3:1's) ran the 20 foot distance in 9 seconds, indicating a scale 24 MPH.
This is going to be the new "project", it will be gettting 3:1's to address the speed and improove driveability, and have an SLU installed.
#20
RE: HL Tank Scale Speeds, Calculated
Did this when I got my Panzer III with Nylon gears and it came out to 23MPH
I was surprised to say the least.
Haven't done my Pershing yet, it has Max400 Motors in it & factory metal boxes.
I couldn't believe how much the DBC slowed it down. It doesn't really matter much, it was just more than I thought it would be.
I used this guys calculator since Mathematics and myself are like oil & water.
I'm one of those calculator dependent people
http://jbwid.com/art74i.htm