most laws are voluntary compliance:
speed limits, tax evasion, and the law against murder are all voluntary compliance
with a punitive consequence for the folks caught not complying.

but the OP made it pretty clear
he know some will choose to do what they wish and some will choose to do as they are told,
and he simply asked how many are choosing A vs B


As for AMA members being free to do as they wish at AMA clubs,
is that really how a Community Based Standards Org runs its chartered clubs...
is that how we are presenting ourselves to the FAA, a wildbunch of guys free to do as they wish?
Or are we trying to claim there's some kind of oversight and control by the standards org as 'self-regulating'?
We can be self regulating, or we can be free to break our own rules... we cant be both