It's interesting the turn this thread has taken from my original question!
I want to emphasize that my question was just that, a question. No one was upset about the judges' uncertainty, no one felt cheated. I asked the question so I'd know the proper ruling when something like that happens when I'm serving as a judge.

On the topic of judging in general...I'm in my third season of pattern and have been very satisfied with the judging. I've always been treated fairly, even generously and the scores I receive are remarkably close between the two judges.
Thanks, guys.

Scott