giles is no good. bad stall. no good right off the trainer. I have a friend(experienced pilot) who had one and lost it to stall. it just kept snap rolling into the ground.

UCD or magic extra are gonna be better because they both will fly very slowly without stalling. this is good but will teach you bad habits. these are 3D planes and cant be flown really fast.

on low rates these are easy to deal with then you get better you can crank it up for some 3D.

on a budget i would lean toward the magic extra. ive seen one 3D nicely w/ a TTpro.46. Most people with a UCD .46 put way bigger engines in them. I have one w/TTpro.61 and like it alot. it was my 3rd and 4th glow powered plane(crashed my 1st UCD 4 times b4 i retired it)

hope this helps