I have played AFP, AFPD, and G3 and man they are awsome simulators. However, AFP(D) stands out in graphics and simulation. There is a pretty good improvement from AFP to AFPD too but AFP is very solid too. G3 is also a good simulator, I just wish that AFP(D) had an online feature like G3.... Moreover, I believe that afpd is the best because of it's excellent graphics and awsome simulation, but I still enjoy playing each sim. (Please understand these are my opinions, thanks. )
OMG, finally I'm going to fly this weekend!!!!(real life) yeaaaaahhhhhhhh (I've been very busy with school and sports )

Matt