I would think it unlikely that anyone would be able to give an unbiased opinion, unless like redwings, they own multiple simulators and can go back and forth between them to compair. I have G3 and have no interest in spending another $400.00+ for other simulators to compair. I have minutes on FSone. However, I fly Mode 1, so I don't think flying FSOne in Mode 2 for a couple minutes would be a fair apprasial of FSOne. I can tell you I am happy with my G3 (which was recently upgraded to G3.5 for free).