Yup, that's what I said. Thanks for attempting to distort that which is solid advice. There's more to getting meaningful advice than to take what everyone says at face value. And yes, as his instructor will likely be helping him, it's worthwhile to consult with the instructor. Nothing says that the instructor can't be just as much of a brand-loyal zealot as some people here. If that's the case, it may well be worth going along to get along when it comes to that first engine purchase.