STL,
I am a supporter of AMA clubs, I like flying there, and I am active in these clubs at many levels. I also like attending fly-ins, and IMAC competitions which require AMA membership. In fact, in general, I like being an AMA member and supporting my hobby. I am not an "AMA Hater" like many seem to be.

I do not like getting an email like this with no mention of being solicited to purchase something, under the guise of collecting information. The first thing that was said to me by the agent on the phone was something like. "Thank you for calling, we will ask a few questions, and also offer you the opportunity to support the AMA by purchasing your own copy of the directory. Can I count on you to support the AMA?". If AMA is not receiving any revenue from this I would be very surprised since a big p[art of the sales pressure is to "support the AMA". I was asked questions, and repeatedly solicited to buy a directory. This would have been much less sleazy if the letter had had a line in it similar to this, "In addition to providing your Biographical information, you will be given the opportunity to purchase a copy of the directory". At least this would have let me know, that this call would have a sales component to it. Knowing this, I would not have made the call.

As it is, it is too close to typical telemarketing methods, and is inappropriate for a membership organization. The previous unsolicited CD-ROM episode (which AMA management has acknowledged was not well handled), in combination with this are causing me to question AMA methods.

My problem, is that I wanted to post a message to the AMA regarding my feelings about this. I am assuming, possibly incorrectly, that AMA monitors these forums. I also wanted to see if other members agree with my view. If they do, maybe a large negative response will cause AMA management to re-think their methods. I guess I should also write a direct e-mail to the president of AMA.