The guy who hatched such an obviously flawed plan, most likely. Most people expect that leadership involves taking credit for both the good and the bad. In here, it seems that Horrace gets a free pass from some of you. Do you want a guy who uses unethical methods to enact ineffective and logically-flawed plans to be EVP?

I mean, really. Let's get beyond your chosen persona for just a moment, and talk like reasonable people. If a guy can't answer a question without making people do a song and dance for no good reason, is he a straight shooter? I don't think so. I wouldn't want him cutting my lawn, let alone trying to work with others.