Hello, I'm sorry you are having a problem with another RCU member. Are you referring to the rating you received in August 2008? There were no complaints filed by you or the other member so our staff did not remove any ratings from this transaction. Reading through the posts made by you and the seller in the ad, he offered to send you a refund if you would return the charger to him to verify it was not functional. Did you take him up on his offer?