RCU Forums - View Single Post - Future of the Scalemasters?
View Single Post
Old 11-09-2009 | 10:51 PM
  #76  
allanflowers's Avatar
allanflowers
 
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,798
Received 42 Likes on 32 Posts
From: San Diego, CA
Default RE: Future of the Scalemasters?


ORIGINAL: ChazM


My comments on your post are in Bold/Italics.

Isn't it true that the POINT SPREAD at the end of static judging is what is hard to overcome in the flight scores, not the placement? NOPE, If you mean the spread between, say, 1st and 10th “static place”. It’s one’s static score delta that is hard to overcome with flight scores.

If the first place static is 99 and tenth place static is 97, then that tenth place guy (or gal) has to make up 2 points. Nope. He has to fly 6+ points better to beat him/her.

If first place static is 99 and SECOND place static is 95, then the second place guy has to make up 4 points. NOPE. He has to score a total flight score (of say, 3 rounds) of 12+ points to beat him/her.

If the flight competition was done first, the people back in the field would feel like they have a hard time to catch up. Since static competition is done first, it is the other way around. NO Comment.

This contest is equally about both static and flying and that shouldn't be changed. If you can't excel at both, you shouldn't be in the top rank. Nope. Static and flying are not equal in any sense. Static scores are weighted. Total score is the average of 3 best flight scores (assuming 4-5 rounds were flown) plus the Static score.

A high Static score of more than 2 is almost always a sure winner. That’s my assessment anyway. I’ve been there with a static of 97 chasing a 99 static. Needless to say, I didn’t fly 6+ points better then he did. There’s only 1 winner in this game. The rest fight for placement that will get them qualified.
/chuck
I just reread the Scale Masters rules and I stand by my earlier statement totally. It is true the the flight scores are an average of several flights (probably 3 of 4 or five but possibly only one flight if that is all the entrant has done). If a contestant is 2 points down from another guy after the static, he has to have a flight score average of 2 points better than the other guy to tie him, more to win.

I appreciate the fact that it is hard to get high flight scores consistantly, round after round, but that is true for everybody, including the guy who had the higher static score.

AGAIN, if the flight competition was first, some people would be whining about the unfairness of that.