Battery Charger advise/basic: 1650nimh
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 549
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Germantown,
TN
OK:
New to sport. I have a trainer {Futaba radios} that I replaced the receiver battery with a 4.8V/1650 mah NIMH battery. My wall charger is only a 50 mah charger.
1. I've been told this wall charger will not fully charge to 1650 mah. true?
2. If so, I need to buy a charger that will {assuming the 1/10 rule} charge at 165 mah for 10 hours to completely charge. true?
3. I've been told the ACE Digipulse charger is a good one. true?
4. Beginner question: Why not just buy a quick field charger and do it this way all the time? Is this not good for the battery?
New to sport. I have a trainer {Futaba radios} that I replaced the receiver battery with a 4.8V/1650 mah NIMH battery. My wall charger is only a 50 mah charger.
1. I've been told this wall charger will not fully charge to 1650 mah. true?
2. If so, I need to buy a charger that will {assuming the 1/10 rule} charge at 165 mah for 10 hours to completely charge. true?
3. I've been told the ACE Digipulse charger is a good one. true?
4. Beginner question: Why not just buy a quick field charger and do it this way all the time? Is this not good for the battery?
#2

My Feedback: (12)
ORIGINAL: jigeye
OK:
New to sport. I have a trainer {Futaba radios} that I replaced the receiver battery with a 4.8V/1650 mah NIMH battery. My wall charger is only a 50 mah charger.
1. I've been told this wall charger will not fully charge to 1650 mah. true?
OK:
New to sport. I have a trainer {Futaba radios} that I replaced the receiver battery with a 4.8V/1650 mah NIMH battery. My wall charger is only a 50 mah charger.
1. I've been told this wall charger will not fully charge to 1650 mah. true?
2. If so, I need to buy a charger that will {assuming the 1/10 rule} charge at 165 mah for 10 hours to completely charge. true?
3. I've been told the ACE Digipulse charger is a good one. true?
4. Beginner question: Why not just buy a quick field charger and do it this way all the time? Is this not good for the battery?
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 126
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Billings,
MT
Buy a Sirius charger and be done with it. They are the best chargers available IMO. I charge both rx and tx with mine and havn't used a wall charger in 6 years. Central Hobbies sells them for a little over $100 online.
Cheers and enjoy!
Cheers and enjoy!
#4
Senior Member
My Feedback: (6)
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 1,815
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Lincoln,
NE
1. The problem with charging below 1/10 C is that internal cell losses become a significant % of the charge current. The result is the charger spends a lot of its energy on just keeping the cells from discharging, and little goes into actually charging the pack. While technically it may be possible to charge a battery at less than 1/10 C, it is far from ideal.
2. 165ma charge rate is 1/10 C for a 1650mah pack. This is the ideal trickle, or slow charge rate. Don’t need to exactly hit this figure, i.e. 150ma or 200ma is close enough. You could however charge much faster if you want too.
3. I’m not familiar with the ACE. I’ve heard of it, but I’ve never used one. I use Sirius and Triton chargers. Mainly I use the Sirius chargers, and just use the Tritons for LiPos and pack capacity testing. Both the Sirius and Triton are very fine and work well.
4. You can quick field charge, but it is a bit harder on the pack. It will shorten the life (number of charge/discharge cycles) of the pack. Some cells deal better with high charge rates as they are designed for this use, other cells do worse. The actual reduction in battery life is generally not terribly significant if you keep the charge rate at 1C or below, but it will depend on the cells. In general, I charge nearly everything at 0.5C to 1C. But occasionally I will trickle charge a pack to help balance cells and perform a discharge to test capacity. So in that respect, it may be a good idea also have a way to trickle charge and to test pack capacity. This could be the same unit as the charger, or separate unit(s.)
2. 165ma charge rate is 1/10 C for a 1650mah pack. This is the ideal trickle, or slow charge rate. Don’t need to exactly hit this figure, i.e. 150ma or 200ma is close enough. You could however charge much faster if you want too.
3. I’m not familiar with the ACE. I’ve heard of it, but I’ve never used one. I use Sirius and Triton chargers. Mainly I use the Sirius chargers, and just use the Tritons for LiPos and pack capacity testing. Both the Sirius and Triton are very fine and work well.
4. You can quick field charge, but it is a bit harder on the pack. It will shorten the life (number of charge/discharge cycles) of the pack. Some cells deal better with high charge rates as they are designed for this use, other cells do worse. The actual reduction in battery life is generally not terribly significant if you keep the charge rate at 1C or below, but it will depend on the cells. In general, I charge nearly everything at 0.5C to 1C. But occasionally I will trickle charge a pack to help balance cells and perform a discharge to test capacity. So in that respect, it may be a good idea also have a way to trickle charge and to test pack capacity. This could be the same unit as the charger, or separate unit(s.)
#5
Junior Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 19
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: fairland,
OK,
Howdy, I have been using the wall charger that came with my Airtronics radio the packs and radio are 1 yr. old my tx. now only charges to 10.5 volts when it used to hit 11.2 or more right off the charger. I am wondering what should I do and about how to cycle them Ive run them down and recharged several times in the last year I'm afraid my capacity has went out the window, don't know about the reciever pack haven't checked it with a voltmeter in a long time some advice please. Thanks
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 968
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: College Station,
TX
ORIGINAL: fishmissile2000
Howdy, I have been using the wall charger that came with my Airtronics radio the packs and radio are 1 yr. old my tx. now only charges to 10.5 volts when it used to hit 11.2 or more right off the charger. I am wondering what should I do and about how to cycle them Ive run them down and recharged several times in the last year I'm afraid my capacity has went out the window, don't know about the reciever pack haven't checked it with a voltmeter in a long time some advice please. Thanks
Howdy, I have been using the wall charger that came with my Airtronics radio the packs and radio are 1 yr. old my tx. now only charges to 10.5 volts when it used to hit 11.2 or more right off the charger. I am wondering what should I do and about how to cycle them Ive run them down and recharged several times in the last year I'm afraid my capacity has went out the window, don't know about the reciever pack haven't checked it with a voltmeter in a long time some advice please. Thanks



